As an update - and a bittersweet one - I pulled out a Patricia bag in black that I bought from Eb@y and it was unused with original tissue still inside. I had been saving it as an easy cleanup and just applied Leather CPR without a bath since it looks unused. Well just as with the Stewardess some dye lifted off as I was cleaning it! Now I am so disappointed and I am wondering whether being unused makes these dyes fragile over time. Or whether Leather CPR just doesn't mix with certain dye lots. The loss is most obvious as I clean the inner pocket with the creed patch.
I feel like throwing out my tube of Leather CPR now. I am so disgusted at this experience!
I wish I could pass these on as a redo rehab project! They are going to the Hold pile for now. I thought it couldn't get simpler than an all black essentially new bag and it just isn't working.
I don't think Leather CPR is the culprit here...without having washed the bag, I'm not sure you really know what's on the surface. And depending on her age and how she was stored by previous owner (despite being unused), it might just be a little surface dirt that the CPR is picking up. Maybe bathing the bag is a good solution. Try to not be discouraged. Every bag is different, so every rehab is too...and it does take a little practice. Keep at it and let us know your progress...we're here to help if we can.
I'm sorry to hear you are still having trouble. I hope you have some luck with waterproofing your bags to prevent color transfer.
I don't think it is the Leather CPR that is lifting the dye. Don't you think that it would happen with any conditioner or any liquid for that matter? The dyes themselves are the culprits, and it is impossible to predict which ones aren't colorfast.
Since I started rehabbing back in February, I've seen bags lose LOTS of color in the bath, and others hardly any at all. Same goes for conditioning. I agree that the dye is likely the issue, and stick with my suggestion that a bath is in order.
Sorry you are having a hard time of it! Please don't get discouraged though. I have rehabbed quite a few bags (many NYC) and always use Blackrocks. The dye always seems to lift in varying degrees no matter what the color of the bag. I have a gorgeous burgandy Stewardess that left a good amount of color on the towel that I buffed her out with and she still looks amazing with great depth of color. I have also rehabbed black vintage bags with almost no color transfer on my buffing towel.
I have never had a problem with color transfer from any of them on my wallet, cosmetic bag etc (which are also Coach vintage leather). Again, I think it's normal to lose some color when conditioning a piece, just as when bathing it. For the most part after conditioning/moisturizing the color usually deepens and intensifies after regaining the needed moisture. Although I am certainly not an expert I don't think the dyes are becoming fragile over time. Vintage Coach glove tanned leather has to be one of the most durable leathers I have ever seen. I am stumped as to why you are losing a great deal of color on your projects. I have never tried Leather CPR but I know many of our fellow rehabbers swear by it. Maybe someone else can chime in with an opinion as well. Let us know how it's going!![]()
Well said. I've had similar experiences. I've always used Leather CPR after a bath, while the leather is still damp. Usually 2 rounds with a day in between. Then Blackrocks, also twice with a day in between. The Leather CPR makes the leather fat and happy and the Blackrocks makes a nice, lustrous finish.
Good Luck GoStanford...I hope this helps!