I have a Coach quality horror story myself! I instantly fell in love with the Coach Poppy Pushlock Satchel in Camelia (pink) when I saw it but behaved myself and waited until the 25% off sale. Then I was in there like lightning. I switched all my stuff right into it and carried it happily for about a week. Now, I baby my purses. I can use a purse off and on for 2 years and I could still say it's new and have someone believe me. So after a week, I noticed that my beautiful PINK bag was turning white on the bottom corners where the waxed leather was completely wearing off. Then, of course, this white was picking up dirt and suddenly my bag looked like I was tossing it on the floor of a public bus everyday (when I was, of course, escorting it around town on the passenger seat of my car). I was horrified! So I took it back to the FP Coach where I got it and the manager was very nice. She agreed that should not be happening. So she shipped it back to their "repair" center in Jacksonville, FL to be fixed free of charge. And the waiting game began...
About 3 weeks later I got a box from Coach in the mail. I was so excited to have my beautiful bag back. So I opened the box... and found it simply tossed inside with no protection along with a note. Before even reading the note, I saw that they had DONE NOTHING! No repair. The note informed me that nothing was wrong with it, it was normal wear. The leather rubbing off and turning dirt brown after 2 weeks of light carrying and never touching the ground is "normal wear"?!
So I called the Coach boutique and explained all of this to the manager, who was surprised, but couldn't really do anything else. After going on about how disappointed I was with Coach, she offered an exchange for another one, but in a different color as the pink had sold out. I didn't want another cheap bag that was just going to get ruined in 2 weeks again! I wanted a full refund. This, she couldn't do. I told her I would never buy from Coach again if this is how their quality and customer service is. If they wanted to screw me over and keep my $300+ and lose every penny that I would have spent in the future (and this would ahve been far more than $300, and had been thousands before this incident), then fine.
So the manager (who was very nice through all of this) told me that she would talk to the District Manager and then get back to me. She told me it might take a week because the DM was on vacation. I was pleasantly surprised when she called me back 3 days later. My one time refund was approved.
Of course, when I brought it in to return, the people in the store had no idea what was going on, and even though they found a note laying around about it, they still had to email and then call the boss to make sure that it was ok, which took FOREVER and was so stupid since they had a note about the situation! But in the end, I got my refund...
Still, I'm very careful about what I buy from Coach now. Their older items (Hampton, Soho, circa pre 2005) were so amazing and tought and durable. I sold a wallet from back then the other day that still looked brand new! And that's before I was so gentle with my purse goodies, that wallet got quite a workout and didn't even break a sweat!
I'll stick to the Coach outlet now... at least the cheap outlet prices match the cheap quality.