I think I like the card cases better than the Dylan 8s. Just because they're less bulky; Dylan 8 seems like it could overwhelm a bag or look like a wallet on the outside of a bag which isn't very safe. Card cases are cute, small and I think can work in more different ways. Ultimately personal preference I suppose.
On another subject....
I've said this before but, I'm confused as to why everyone is saying "X left" about nearly every item from Fall 2017. Am I to believe that all these items that Coach premiered during their runway show were secretly all sold out to a select few? What exactly would be the point of that? I can't think of a single high-end designer (except maybe a couture collection which only makes one of each gown or some exclusive pieces from ultra high-end brands) that sells out all their good stuff before it gets to stores. If I wasn't a member of these forums, I would never know about calling to order before things come out and probably wouldn't be able to locate half the style numbers. So I'd never be able to get any items from any collection?
I'm over the hype at this point, if they really made like 50 of a bag or a charm then I guess it's not for me. I like to see all my options in front of me, with actual details and photos (at the very least the ability to see both sides of an item before ordering). I would be shocked if this is the business strategy Coach has taken up, since it's pretty much the worst money making idea ever and would make them even more exclusive than the most coveted runway designers (which I also doubt they're going for here).
I love seeing a new collection as it's hitting the runways, and obsessing over finding clues and hints about what items will be sold as much as the next person, but I don't like the frantic feeling of seeing some cool pieces and feeling like 'omg 3 left order now or you'll never have anything like this'. If I wasn't on a self-inflicted Coach ban I'd be ordering out of serious FOMO.
Everyone that has been able to secure pieces already: big congrats and I'm so excited for you and I love seeing your photos. I just wanted to say what I said above in case other people aren't as decided on particular pieces and are afraid they won't have time to decide.
I agree with what you're saying. I like the ability to walk into a store and see all of my options and make a smart decision on my purchase. It's unfair to a lot of people as you said. But a lot of brands ((and hopefully Coach)) do reserve a number of the pieces on the side to be shipped out to stores when the collection is released so that people who were unable to pre-order can walk into the store and get it themselves. I guess the best solution is to talk with an SA asap if you see something you are interested in purchasing so that they keep you updated.