Oh goodness no worries, it was a GOOD fake. If I hadn't been able to pull out a few other Venetias to compare, I'm not sure I would have figured it out. My first clue was the weight seeming slightly off and the leather just felt different, enough to give me pause to really go over it with a fine tooth comb. On very close inspection I realized the zipper pulls, while identical to the ones on my other bags, all had the MJ name on the wrong side, facing the wrong way. The leather on the strap for the buckle was thinner and less rigid. The inner zipper opened in the opposite direction, on the inner flap pocket the flap itself did not have any sort of internal reinforcing, the stitching on the front pockets was continuous in an area that on every other soft calf bag I have is broken up. The suede lining was thinner. Honestly all very small, I had to REALLY go over the bag physically.
I think I have 15 of the soft calf classics, all bought through eBay and similar sites, and it's pretty incredible I've gone this long without getting a fake. And even with my carrying one of those bags every day for the past ten years, had the weight of this one not caught my attention, I probably never would have looked closer - it's that good. I initiated the return stating it was counterfeit, and without replying or asking any questions she immediately started the return process on her end. The silver lining is now I won't feel so guilty about that peacock Stella that I might have picked up this week.