I am in desperate need of sizing help. I just purchased some oiled leather arizona's with soft foot bed in iron in a 36 regular from zappos. I'm not sure if my strap adjustment is right. I'm having pain on top of my foot under the second strap closest to my ankle. I have it in the 2nd hole from the middle and can fit a finger underneath. If I go to the last hole it feels tight. I almost need a hole in between the two. Do you think I should put some type of padding on the inside of the strap? I've had them about 3 weeks and have been breaking them in. I have a trip to New York coming up and would like to wear them. I have the worst luck with shoes and have constantly been getting blisters. I tore my feet up with some Sanucks at Summerfest and I've had them for awhile and wear them all the time. Any suggestions would be appreciated!