The chevron looks unique, if it's seasonal I would think to get that, since it may or may not come back. But on the flip side, boys are going up in price for cruise so this makes it tougher. Hmmmmmm it also depends what you have already in your collection. Like if you always wanted a boy and never bought it, then go get the boy..... Sorry I'm not much help. But I think ultimately I would go for the boy..... Even tho I love the chevron on the flap too.