I like both— is there a significant price difference? Does that play into your decision?
I am rather partial to phone holders, and searched up and down for 2 years before finding one earlier this year. I just got a second last month, so I wholeheartedly endorse them. This color is fabulous, bright, summery, unusual. Definitely eye-catching. I would hate to pass it up if you really like it.
The jacket is cute, pretty neutral. Very flattering fit. But would you wear it daily? Weekly? As an outer layer, or top? Many people use cost per wear as a yardstick.
But, if someone else is paying… then you can come back later for the less expensive item.