Go for the small with 6 diamonds. I have 2 small love, one with 6 diamonds and one without. I wear them both together and I love it. It doesn't feel too much for everyday wear. I have a classic love as well that I stopped wearing because I kept dinging it and banging it everywhere and the scratches show so much. My small love on the other hand feels soooo comfortable. I sometimes wear both small loves together or just one alone. They look great either way. if you're ready to buy now, I would get the diamond version before they go up again in price.