I have tried a million and one mascaras. I have pretty long eyelashes but my straight asian eyes have a hard time holding curl unless its a waterproof formula. Some of the mascaras that drooped my eyelashes completely down were ysl, le volume de chanel, diorshow, lancome hypnose,...I can see these mascaras working out for people without a curl problem. Anyways, my favorite is maybeline colossal volume in waterproof! It works very well, but I am looking for something that is blacker. I have been using maybelline everyday for about 2 years now. Before, I was using diorshow blackout waterproof, which was great but got clumpy fast.