As to your comment about the smaller items sliding underneath the center pouch, I thought I'd share what I did with my smaller Bandit. I never intended to use the pouch on its own so I used double-sided velcro and attached the bottom of the pouch to the bottom of the bag inside. It works remarkably well. I've even taken the pouch out and the velcro off and there was no damage to either side it was sticking to. Nothing slides under and it provides a nicely divided bag.I think several factors: the weight of the bandit, which is nothing for me, since I'm used to substantial bags. Then the double handles can get in the way when opening/looking for things. Furthermore, the removable leather pouch is a great idea, but smaller items can slide around underneath-making the search for small things a pain. Any of these can be deal breakers to people, but I love the shape, style and color (got it in peony), so I'll just work around them.
I tried the Bedford, and while I think it's a very nice bag, it is not going to work for me. It's simply too big and I'm not fond of a big dark hole of a bag. I'll be curious how well this one sells.