the tabs are a bit thinner, the 'brass' not brass, the shape is maybe 90% right, but not 100% spot on. i was tempted to keep it but a) i knew i could never sell it; and b) the fact that it wasn't 'authentic' just bothered me no end, even though it was remarkably well made -- thick leather, etc. the person from whom i bought it was quite gracious and took it back immediately. i was just stunned, though, since i think i have seen dozens of these bags, and have never seen a fake one before. i guess no bag is immune.