This one has red flags too. Not just the zipper pull - I've only seen metal ring pulls with that extra crescent of metal on fakes, but it usually says Coach on that metal bit on the fakes. Plant code E belongs only to Italy, and both of your Tafts have mid to late 1995 year codes but are still using the older creed stamp with the previous wording and the country of origin at the bottom instead of in the second line of the creed. Maybe there were still a few older stamp in use (Italy used the older format for a long time but the stamp itself had been modernized and the Coach logo updated). Here's a different style bag also from the D plant like the first Taft and it already has the new creed - again, maybe both styles were being used at the same time? I don't know and I doubt if anyone else does either, unfortunately.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/Coach-Women...015?pt=US_CSA_WH_Handbags&hash=item4d02700ac7
But an Italy code should never have been used in a Made in the US bag. Just looking through the Italian-made Madisons currently for sale, I'm seeing 1995 month codes A, G, and E, and a J all shown as from Italy in one of my own bags. An H code with a US creed just sounds odd, it's right in the middle of the other months and it doesn't seem like it should be there.
I can't be sure about either one. None of the other Tafts currently listed have that zipper pull and they're not from the right time period either so they're not much help. They may be genuine bags with a few strange mistakes, it's impossible to tell without a lot more comparing and at the moment there doesn't seem to be anything to compare them to, since I'm the only person crazy enough to obsess about these kinds of things.
) 
