Authenticate this COACH

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Status
Not open for further replies.
How about these two? Thanks! :smile1:

Item: AUTHENTIC COACH LRG MADISON EXOTIC SOFIA BAG 15954 NWT
Listing number: 110637336948
Seller: mittens139
Link: http://cgi.ebay.com/AUTHENTIC-COACH-LRG-MADISON-EXOTIC-SOFIA-BAG-15954-NWT-/110637336948?pt=US_CSA_WH_Handbags&hash=item19c27fc974#ht_851wt_907

Item: NWT COACH MADISON Embosed Leather SOPHIA SATCHEL 15954
Listing number: 150590192709
Seller: allure700
Link: http://cgi.ebay.com/NWT-COACH-MADISON-Embosed-Leather-SOPHIA-SATCHEL-15954-/150590192709?pt=US_CSA_WH_Handbags&hash=item230fdffc45#ht_849wt_1141

Any idea on these? Thanks in advance.
 
Originally Posted by Hyacinth Originally Posted by Hyacinth
Unfortunately the high-volume and high-Feedback sellers often get breaks from Ebay that other sellers don't. And it takes a lot more reports to get rid of their listings. That seller does high numbers, so it's going to take more than 2 or 3 reports to take it down, and the seller bbigalow will probably re-list his fakes anyway because Ebay doesn't bother to check, it's up to the unpaid help like us to do it.

Something to remember too is that Ebay only allows one report per day against a seller from each poster. Anyone who gets frustrated and sends in a dozen reports of the same fake listing one after the other is wasting their time because only one report counts, the rest just pull your report farther back in line.




Status??? Ebay members who aren't high volume buyers or sellers have NO status, so you can't hurt what you don't have. Sad but true. We're cows whose only reason for existence is to be milked of every ounce of money we have.

Next - if you only report one item number that's all they'll look at and that's all they're supposed to remove. You can report up to 10 listings per seller in each report box though unless Ebay is using different report boxes for different users, which they probably do. You can report a THOUSAND listings by the same seller in one day, you just can't report the SAME item listing over and over.

And never tell them "you THINK something's fake". If you're not positive, you can't report. If YOU don't know if something's fake, the robots in wheatever country Ebay is handling reports out of won't know either.

And of course you should never report something unless you're absolutely sure, and it's been verified by one of the experts. Always keep in mind what I posted in the most recent Fakes List:
"...remember, just because a Coach item seems to have the right style number, or looks just like the picture from Coach's website, or the C's line up correctly, OR IT HAS YKK ZIPPERS, that DOESN"T mean it's genuine.

And just because you haven't seen it before, or can't find it on Google, or don't like it, or think that "Coach couldn't possibly have made something that ugly" doesn't mean it's fake."


thanks so much. I just figured out how to report more than one item of a seller in one report. And I only report them if I'm really sure. So do you think the people from Ebay remove an item just based on the number of reports they receive or the feedback rating of the seller? They don't have anybody that confirms authenticity that works there? That probably explains why I have seen so many fake Chanels sold for a fortune, when it was obvious the serial number was fake.

The number of reports Ebay received has an effect on whether or not listings are removed. No one at Ebay is a trained authenticator, that's why they need so much free help from the members. The previous members of the Trust & Safety departmemt were not experts but had read more than enough reports to know that "C's outside & inside" pretty much was solid proof that a bag was fake and were pretty well-versed in common signs of fakes. One or two even cared enough about the fakes problem to actually join some of the fakes-busting forums and interact with the posters. Unfortunately all of those experienced T&S members have been "permanently laid off" - basically fired, because they were too expensive to keep and did their jobs TOO well. (Thank you Ryan and the other few, wherever you are, who tried to do a good job for an employer who just didn't give a damn).

Supposedly each manufacturer has a VeRO rep working with Ebay who has final say on what gets removed and what doesn't but while the VeRO reps from some companies like Chanel can be deliberately overzealous and remove genuine listings just because they don't like competition from auction sites, the Coach VeRO rep seems to be a close relative of The Invisible Man. There probably IS a Coach VeRO rep but I've never seen any solid evidence of it. Based on some of the listings that have AND haven't been removed, Coach's VeRO rep knows less about genuine and fake Coach than most of this forum's posters.

So the blind are leading the blind, and CEO Donahue is walking in the footsteps of Meg Whitman and only cares about the bottom line - the fakes problem will continue as long as greed continues to motivate Ebay's executives.

But we have to keep trying.
 

Attachments

  • 1766_d1.jpg
    1766_d1.jpg
    24 KB · Views: 48
Originally Posted by Hyacinth The first one's ok. All the "Coaches" from rynomatt are obvious and admitted fakes.

Thanks Hyacinth! I should have read the the listing first before posting:shame:.

No problem. Remember, take a little extra time to look at the entire listing if you're not sure about authenticity. Sometimes the answer is right in front of you. Don't try to report every single fake every single day, it can't be done. Also remember that right along with the style and the fabric pattern, the creed and serial number are two of the most important indicators if something's authentic or not.

Read the listing and read the creed.
 
How about these two? Thanks! :smile1:

Item: AUTHENTIC COACH LRG MADISON EXOTIC SOFIA BAG 15954 NWT
Listing number: 110637336948
Seller: mittens139
Link: http://cgi.ebay.com/AUTHENTIC-COACH..._WH_Handbags&hash=item19c27fc974#ht_851wt_907

Item: NWT COACH MADISON Embosed Leather SOPHIA SATCHEL 15954
Listing number: 150590192709
Seller: allure700
Link: http://cgi.ebay.com/NWT-COACH-MADIS...WH_Handbags&hash=item230fdffc45#ht_849wt_1141

Any idea on these? Thanks in advance.
Sorry. I intended to come back to these and forgot.

I think they look okay.
 
Is this authentic? I've seen a couple of them floating around on ebay. If so, when where they sold?

Item: Coach Ipod Case
Listing #: 20710478951
Seller: specialfinds40
Link: http://cgi.ebay.com/Coach-Ipod-Case...Accessories&hash=item1c1ae7bc67#ht_720wt_1139
Coach used to sell them but they discontinued them because Apple kept changing the sizes of the iPods and Coach couldn't keep up with them.

So those that are being sold now are probably about 4 or so years old.

I believe the style number of the ladybug case that you've asked about is 2649 although a search for that style number probably won't be much help. Most people probably didn't save the tag from that long ago.
 
Personally never seen this version. I have the brown suede version.

COACH Poppy floral/flower PINK Crossbody handbag/bag
250804373229
aroosak7777
http://cgi.ebay.com/COACH-Poppy-flo...H_Handbags&hash=item3a651b06ed#ht_9650wt_1139

I've never seen that particular style before but it's very possible that it's genuine. We'd really need to see a clear close-up of the creed and serial number to be sure though. But it's close enough to the Sig and suede Poppy Hobos in the photos below to be a genuine Poppies for Peace style.
 

Attachments

  • 9260_pink.jpg
    9260_pink.jpg
    30.2 KB · Views: 58
  • 9260_d1.jpg
    9260_d1.jpg
    16 KB · Views: 58
  • 7086_Poppy Sig.jpg
    7086_Poppy Sig.jpg
    29.4 KB · Views: 55
Originally Posted by Hyacinth The first one's ok. All the "Coaches" from rynomatt are obvious and admitted fakes.



No problem. Remember, take a little extra time to look at the entire listing if you're not sure about authenticity. Sometimes the answer is right in front of you. Don't try to report every single fake every single day, it can't be done. Also remember that right along with the style and the fabric pattern, the creed and serial number are two of the most important indicators if something's authentic or not.

Read the listing and read the creed.

Thank you so much Hyacinth!:D
 
do with this what you will but I found a seller: sellthisthat
was selling 2 of the same item. one at a buy it now for 319 and the other has bids. seemed fishy to me and odd. seeing which one sells better? Just thought I'd put it out there. Here's one of the links. No need to respond or anything if you dont want to but Im just warning people in case they bid on one heres the link:

http://cgi.ebay.com/Coach-15280-Ale...466?pt=US_CSA_WH_Handbags&hash=item3cb6f273f2
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top