Are diamonds by the yard worth it?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

I just ordered a beautiful new DBTY-style necklace on Etsy! I got it in YG to match my bracelet that I have. It's a 0.12ct diamond, G Color VS-SI Clarity - for around 1/10th of the price of the Tiffany equivalent! I paid £160 :panic: can't wait for it to arrive! I was debating between WG and YG for a few days, but decided on YG as I thought it would make the diamond pop. Screenshot 2022-01-20 at 15.54.33.png
 
I ended up ordering both, DBTY and Legers. Now I’m more confused about which one I should keep. Let me know your thoughts, please ❤
1 - SM Cartier Ledger
2 - DBTY 0.22

View attachment 5295743

View attachment 5295744

I prefer the bottom one. The diamond just stands out that much more.

I have the 5 diamond bracelet from the collection and I LOVE it. The only thing I don't love is that it's scratchy on the skin. under the diamond. Does anyone else get this?
 
  • Like
Reactions: marisa1984
I had one made through Brian Gavin Diamonds that was more bang for my buck than Tiffany. I wear the necklace quite frequently. I highly recommend them. I was able to choose the stone from their inventory.
 
I’ve heard that the bezel set diamond by the yard necklace flips a lot? For those of you who own one is that true? What carat weight is your diamond? Is this issue less common with larger carat weights?
thank you
 
For me, I didn't think it was worth it. I had a diamond station bracelet made which is very similar to the DBTY 5 stone bracelet. The bracelet retails for around £2600 in the UK in yellow gold - I got mine for £250 by having it made by a jeweller on Etsy. It has the same diamond ttcw and is also 18k YG. I would never usually do this, but with such a simple design with such a high mark-up, I decided I didn't want to pay the premium. I wear it with my Love and JUC and it looks beautiful.

If you still want a 'branded' bracelet, Aspinal of London make a bracelet identical to the DBTY in WG and YG! https://www.aspinaloflondon.com/products/celeste-18ct-gold-diamond-bracelet?currency=GBP

View attachment 5175577View attachment 5175578
Would you mind sharing the etsy seller please? Thanks so much!
 
Updating this to say I still wear my DBTY-style bracelet that I had made by an Etsy jeweller! I managed to break one of the rings on it so I had to have it repaired by my local jeweller. It looks beautiful with my Love and I don’t actually mind that they intertwine with each other as they move. Every so often, you get a glimmer of a diamond from underneath the love and it looks beautiful :love:

5F977673-4D21-48E0-931D-38954F141C91.jpeg
 
Does anyone have a DBTY or Diamant Legers/Cartier d’Amour necklace in a white metal? I think the appearance of silver, WG, or platinum helps diamonds look larger.

Would love to see pics, thank you!
 
The DBTY is in Platinum while the Diamant Legers is set in WG. Personally I feel like PT is darker and more grey-ish than WG which really shines brightly. However, I much prefer PT over WG since WG is rhodium plated, which can wear off over time. I have a RG and a PT DBTY and the PT one looks definitely much "cleaner". My RG is in .17 ct which is has a thicker bezel than the PT .20 one I have. The RG DBTY looks larger due its thicker bezel. I also have a Cartier d'Amour RG bracelet in 0.09ct. I feel like the diamonds in the DBTYs are much sparklier than the Cartier d'Amour, however the Cartier one has a thicker (more substantial) chain, which I prefer in a bracelet. If I were to choose a necklace again, I'd say PT DBTY > RG DBTY > Cartier d'Amour, which is also my rating for the shininess of the diamond.

I find the Cartier d'amour a bit overwhelming with its thicker, sparklier chain and its setting, which I prefer in a bracelet but dislike in a necklace.

However, the PT DBTY one pokes a bit (the diamond is sticking out in the back). Personally I don't mind, but if you have sensitive skin, I'd get either a smaller diamond in PT or the RG in a thicker bezel (DBTY in RG with a diamond size up to 0.17 have a thicker bezel than the ones set in YG or PT. Also DBTY in Silver have a thicker bezel, but not sure about the diamond size there), or the Cartier d'Amour, which has no poking problems at all.
 
forgot to add that the RG DBTY with thicker bezel is more V shaped than the PT DBTY, which is more U shaped. I prefer the V-shape more with a round neck top and the U-shape more wich a V-neck top.
 
Top