Anyone Ever Buy and/or Sell on Tradesy?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

I ALWAYS have the boxes scanned, and usually it means waiting in a 30min line (NYC). One time I was stressing out for 4 days because the package was scanned for the first time once it reached the customer. So it missed a number of scans alone the way. If it missed the last one, I would probably be screwed.

Thanks! I kicked myself for not doing it this time. Hopefully it works out at the end.
 
This is so wrong. Are you going to fight back with their "fine" authenticators and send them report?
unfortunately, this is new normal for Tradesy nowadays including pushing returns on sellers, stealing additional commission and holding funds as long as they want.
I would but the bag is already on the way back to me so idk if its worth it. They mailed it back a day before they sent me the email regarding the return. Super shady.
 
I would but the bag is already on the way back to me so idk if its worth it. They mailed it back a day before they sent me the email regarding the return. Super shady.

Ugh, I know the frustration. Tradesy's "expert" authenticators decided that my authentic Navajo woven Proenza Schouler bag was inauthentic because it was missing a code that woven bags dont have. When I fought them on that they leaned on "uneven stampings".

My bag was returned to me just fine, but eventually I was at a loss for what to say to their ineffective customer service team, aside from that Proenza Schouler doesn't make/sell fake Proenza Schouler bags.

What's more, they were unresponsive to my request for the name of a third party authenticator whose determination they would accept. Believing your team can't make mistakes... not the best biz strategy.

This actually reminds me, time to delete my account.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GemsBerry
Just an open question, has anyone here already deleted their account? When I looked into it, it says you have to email them. I wonder why? Poshmark just lets you delete it, no questions asked; you just go under your stats and delete.

I am still holding on to my account, but may consider removing it when changes get worse...which I can see happening just by reading this thread.
 
I sold two items to the same buyer on the same day, sent in separate packages using Tradesy's label. The money for one of the items was released at midnight, which would be the 5th day, but the other one is still being held. The buyer hasn't returned since both items are still showing as sold, and in my closet.
 
Just an open question, has anyone here already deleted their account? When I looked into it, it says you have to email them. I wonder why? Poshmark just lets you delete it, no questions asked; you just go under your stats and delete.

I am still holding on to my account, but may consider removing it when changes get worse...which I can see happening just by reading this thread.
I'd like to think they're interested in why you want to close your account. It could be an opportunity to let them know why you're unhappy and offer suggestions and constructive criticism on how they can improve.
 
I had a beautiful 1960s LV bag that I sold a few weeks ago (sold in 2 days) and someone returned it. Of course the money is on hold, and I see it's already sold in Abby's closet for $50 more. Whatever, I keep waiting for the money. I listed EVER possible flaw, even the ones the bag didn't have. 3 weeks later I get an email that Tradesy decided it wasn't authentic "due to the lack of date code".
WTF?! It's an old bag, of course it wouldn't have a date code. On top of that, I had it professionally authenticated before I bought. Do they just return everything for whatever reason they can come up with??

Had the same thing happen to me this week. Ridiculous.
 
My money was released today at the end of the 7th day. There was no indication that the bag was returned until now. When the money was released the bag moved to Abbey Road's closet and is showing as not available. Is this their new procedure for returns? Maybe they aren't putting them in any of their closets until they have examined the returns and decided not to return to the seller.
 
My money was released today at the end of the 7th day. There was no indication that the bag was returned until now. When the money was released the bag moved to Abbey Road's closet and is showing as not available. Is this their new procedure for returns? Maybe they aren't putting them in any of their closets until they have examined the returns and decided not to return to the seller.
when sellers here say my item was returned, showed up in their closet and already sold, then it was returned to me after 7-14 days, it was hanging in limbo for this period. "not available" doesn't mean sold, unless it was marked as "sold by Abbey R" in your sold items.
Now I see the difference, if your item appears in Tradesy closet it means they accepted return and released your money. that would be less confusing.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: whateve
Top