Which one would you go for...I recently got the Marc by MJ Totally turnlock quinn in STONE. And i have been dying for the AC , but i cant decide which color (especially since i have the MbyMJ in stone which will go with everything)
i'm going against popular opinion here, but i prefer tobacco. the color is so rich and you can really see the distressed finish on the leather. it reminds me of a bbag!
I own the tobacco, but I think if I had to purchase all over again, I would have gone with butterscotch, because a lot of my things just don't go as well with it. both are beautiful colors, just take a look at your wardrobe and think about which would compliment it best.
I ordered the butterscotch first, only to be incredibly disappointed by the leather - it was very dry and kind of crackling. So, I returned the bag and ordered the tobacco color. Tobacco is incredibly rich - has a nice redish undertone.
I like the tobacco but I agree that the butterscotch would go with more outfits however you did say that you got a bag that will go with everything so I don't think you need to think practically anymore. I would say go with your first instinct.