Hi ladies,
Just updating you. I did end up with the plain band, and truly, I love it! It wasn't what I expected when I was looking at bands online and in jewelry cases. Mine fits so well with my ring. It's clean and simple. My fiance surprised me on "mother's day" (we have a cat we refer to as our child) by telling me he's already ordered the ring I love for our anniversary. He's been so sweet to me. The funny thing is, is that I ordered him a plain platinum band for our first anniversary as well (he has a tungsten carbide band now, but he loves burnished platinum).
Also, thanks for the kind words, ladies. People like you make posting in a forum worthwhile, for both the input and the positive atmosphere. There are some haters, but by and large, you're all darlings, and I appreciate you.