I want to utilize the sale and saw these amazing penny loafers inspired heels. It's basically everything that I'm looking for. It has a classic modern feel that will go soooo well with my style. The only thing I'm struggling with is the sizing. I'm in between an 8.5 and size 9 and my feet are wide. For comfort, I typically like to lean more towards a 9. Since it's an open-toed shoe I think maybe an Italian 39. just to be safe maybe even a it 40. My only concern about that is the stretch. How bad would they be? I've had a pair of shoes at a 40 that fit like a dream but after a couple of wears stretched so badly they fall off everytime I wear them. What about a 39.5