I was happily enjoying my YSL Lou camera bag when a lovely tPF’r posted on another thread that she has owned the bag for a little while now and it’s losing its shape.
As I mentioned before, the bag seems decently constructed but, nothing like the quality of my other premier bags - not even close. In contrast, when I got my
Gucci Dionysus last October, it screamed beautifully and carefully done construction.
Both of these are small bags so, it makes sense to do a bit of comparison. (Both bags were purchased new.)
PRICE:
•YSL:
A $1250 retail (with discounts & cash back from Saks & Rakuten, Mr. S paid $659) Great pricing for a premier bag.
• Gucci:
B $1950 retail (with the Hawaii discount, Mr. S paid $1755) Not outrageous for a premier bag but not cheap for a mini bag.
STYLING:
• YSL
A- This is a great looking bag. A quilted camera bag is a classic look and the black w/black hw gives it a striking bit of edge. Additionally, they did a great job with the tassel as the strands(?) are rolled and finished - not raw on one side.
• Gucci:
A+ Squeeeee!!!! OMG! This bag is stupid beautiful. Flap bags are a dime a dozen but, the hardware (beautiful chain, striking Dionysus clasp and Swarovski crystals) on this bag make it a show stopper without ever being in your face.
LEATHER & CONSTRUCTION:
• YSL:
C- Made of calfskin. The leather and construction are soft. The leather doesn’t feel thick and chewy. It’s actually feels on the “thin” side but not bad. Lining is fabric.
I don’t have the right words for it but the stitching or construction feels a little below average. Certainly not on par with other Premier brands. I want to give it a B- but it “feels” like lower quality construction than
Coach bags I’ve seen in stores and the one Kate Spade I own. Shouldn’t premier bags have better construction given the bigger price??? Well, it doesn’t.
And, if it does start losing shape within a year, I will drop the grade to an F. No bag should do that.
• Gucci:
A- Is it possible to gush over construction? This little bag has some of the best construction of any bag I own. The stitching is perfect. The seams and edging are perfect. And, the leather is thick giving the impression of being “chewy” despite the rigidity of the style. Lining is fabric which I’ve come to terms with on most of Gucci’s bags now (that is the only ding I give the bag).
HARDWARE:
• YSL:
D The majority of the hardware (clasps, zipper, etc.) are ok, I’m just not impressed.
But, the logo?? It’s plastic!! I hate plastic on my bags. I’m sorry. I just can’t rate it higher given that.
• Gucci:
A+ Oh. My. Gawd. The hardware is solid and sturdy without being heavy, extremely well made and beautifully designed. Plus, the accents are Swarovski crystals. Yummy sparkly!
FUNCTIONALITY:
• YSL:
A- This bag is great for being on the go. It holds all my essentials with a little room to spare. The adjustable strap makes it shoulder or crossbody carry. And it’s easy to get into. No compromises here.
• Gucci:
B- This mini is a bag for looking cute. LOL! Not for big function. It just fits my bare minimum items which is really all I need when I’m going to cocktails or a fun event with Mr. S or our friends. So, I wish it was a teeny bit bigger but, no complaints. It does what it’s supposed to do.
COMPANY SERVICE:
• YSL:
F I’ve shared my issues with getting a repair on my other YSL bag. I don’t know if I mentioned I have been fighting with Saks and YSL to get the box for this bag. I feel I’d be on my own with any issues on this bag.
• Gucci:
A I have only had one issue with a Gucci product and it was handled seamlessly and easily. Given that Mr. S just had a true nightmare with a Louis Vuitton watch repair (they lost his watch then they sent it to someone else and had to get it back!!!), I remain impressed with Gucci’s service.
OVERALL:
YSL:
B- GUCCI:
A
The YSL fails on some key areas - quality and service. Yet, it’s an adorable bag with great functionality that can be found at a very reasonable price. For these latter reasons, I’m still very happy with the purchase. I feel comfortable with this as my sling around / carefree bag. I don’t expect a lot from it so I won’t worry about it. Because of that, I’ll likely get it to a cost per wear that is tiny and still be able to sell it - if need be - for at or close to what we paid. For those reasons I call it a BUY. But only at a heavily discounted price. It is not worth full price IMHO.
In contrast, the Gucci Dionysus is a no compromise bag. It’s beautiful, it’s classic while still being on trend, it has exceptional quality and it will be a bag I keep for many years to come. I can wear it to cocktails or to the farmers market and it somehow “works”. The price isn’t tiny but it’s in line with other premier bags - many of which don’t have the quality and won’t have the staying power. I’m deliriously happy with this bag and definitely would buy another - albeit likely in the next size up. Overall: STRONG BUY
Hope you enjoyed my analysis. If you have either of these bags, I’d love to hear your take on them.