I do have other black bags but no black satchels as the only one I do have is to big and at the consignment shop. The other is more taupe not really grey .I'm here for you!! I like both but also want to know what you need more in your bag collection/for your wardrobe. Do you already have a lot of black bags or are you searching for more? I think I'm drawn to the gray more! It has a nice taupe undertone.