So, since my disappointment with finding I don’t like the black Pochette Metis enough to buy it, there are a few bags I’ve been weighing up.
I’ve really asked myself - do I need another black bag? And I do think I have a gap in my wardrobe for a trendy, large-ish, everyday black bag. Here’s my current black collection.
Bags I’m happy with, but they’re no necessarily “perfect”
1) Dior WOC - such a convenient clutch. Gets a lot of wear.
2) Givenchy Antigona - this is the small size. I love this, it’s trendy, but it’s very large so I don’t reach for it everyday. It’s more of a “I have a big meeting and need lots of things with me” bag. I like having this option.
3) Soft calf
Prada - I use this a lot when I want to be in carefree settings. The label just hides, if I turn it around and it has great capacity and very comfortable. I don’t think I’ll ever get rid of this.
4) Chanel classic flap. Adore.
5) Mulberry medium Lily. I love the style, I get so many compliments on it, but the chain digs into summer clothes. It’s much more comfortable with winter outfits. So I do think twice before carrying it.
Bags I’m not sure about
1) Gucci Abbey - I have good memories with this bag, it’s held up fantastically well despite being worn so much. I took it out last month for a “Love or leave it” and I found it so comfortable to carry and such a good daily capacity that I just couldn’t get rid of it. But it does look dated. So I struggle with this one.
2) Mulberry scotchgrain. I took this out yesterday and tried it on. Again, it’s really old and I was worried it would look old fashioned (which is why I don’t reach for it) but it looked good. The baguette short strap bags are back in fashion. This Mulberry has this gleaming cognac leather trim and an indestructible caviar type material. So I’m going to try carrying it and decide whether I still want it or not.
In this collection though, I feel that I don’t have a carefree, throw it on everyday, don’t worry about chain digging, good size AND on-trend/classic black bag. It’s a lot to ask from a bag.
I had thought for a year that it would be Pochette Metis, but it wasn’t. Quality and capacity issues.
Then I looked at the Gucci Marmont flap and Dionysus - chain digging and aged hardware issues.
Then I looked at Chanel jumbo - chain digging and weight issues.
Then I looked at Chanel Coco - but I have one I love, in gunmetal and I don’t want to duplicate the style. So that’s a reluctant no.
And so I’ve gone back to look at the YSL large envelope and I like it even more on second view than I did on first. In Amsterdam, I saw the silver hardware, medium size and I thought the mixed quilt looked fussy although it was great otherwise.
Then in London this week, I saw the large size in gold hardware. The mixed quilt looks proportionate and interesting in this size. Capacity is great, chain does not dig at all, it looks really good on me, and I think it will be on-trend/classic for a long time.
So after much deliberation, I’ve ordered it and when it comes I’ll try it on with several outfits at home to decide finally whether or not to keep it. But I’m really excited about it arriving, which has to be a good sign!