I totally understand...
I ordered the denim rogue satchel with snake trim, was torn between that & butterscotch. My SA found a regular rogue in Butterscotch (which I jumped on but still hasn't been confirmed). I have the second gen black regular rogue but absolutely can't get the black rogue satchel out of my head.
As much as I love the black rogue satchel esp at this price, I have to walk away.
I adore my black rogue & I think they are to similar (trying to convince myself here), to own both. I'm also trying to not duplicate colors in my collection as well, so that's another reason I have to walk away.
Good luck with your decision.
I hope you get the butterscotch! I'm trying diversify my collection. My SA showed me the new light saddle suede rogue with oxblood trim (and it is gorgeous!) but I already have 3 reg rogue styles which is why I went with the butterscotch satchel and also passed on the black satchel. We'll see how much I like the butterscotch in person. If it's not a winner I might get the light saddle suede rogue.
I purchased the Butterscotch Rogue satchel and now I've been looking at the black satchel. I have a 1st generation Black Rogue, so I'm trying not to repeat colors. I saw a picture of the Oxblood satchel and it was very nice. I'll try to not buy anymore, but we will see. Decisions, decisions, decisions.......