Absolutely stunninglasmico! I've done the same thing (although not with BBags)... purchase 2 of something because I loved it so much... in time I figured out which one was "the one" and sold the other with no problem... You will have no problem finding a new home for either if you decide to so take your time deciding... Congrats on finding these beauties!!!
They ARE both gorgeous - you can always sell one since that bag is not so easy to find. Or you can put one away and take it out years from now when the original is starting to wear! Or you can alternate regularly and neither will practically EVER show wear! CONGRATS!