I’d like to chime in on this conversation because I had an interesting experience. I, too, was always seeing new items from Chanel listed on
Fashionphile for well above retail. In particular, I noticed that they were selling a beautiful WOC that I had just purchased from the Chanel boutique on their website. I bought the item for $3,525 USD + tax totaling somewhere around $3,700. Fashionphile had the same item listed at like, $5,500 (plus tax) in the same brand new condition as mine. I thought to myself, is FP paying sellers well above what the sellers paid for the item and is that why people are selling their brand new items to them? So I did a little experiment, with no real intention of selling my brand new WOC because I loved it, I submitted photos of it to Fashionphile to see what their offer to me would be. They offered me $3,300. Below retail plus well below what it cost me with taxes even though they were selling that exact same item for thousands more. Moral of the story I guess is that they clearly have personal shoppers and it’s not independent buyers who are arbitrarily buying items and selling it to Fashionphile in hopes of making a profit. By the way, it was this pink beauty here with the gold hardware and candy chain.