Whiskey Shoulder Bag, Ali, or Mandy

If you carry more than basic stuff in your bag I would keep the Ali. I own two Ali's and love them both (whiskey and white). I did have the shoulder bag but returned it as I found it too small for my needs.
 
Well, I've decided to for sure keep the shoulder bag. I did some trying on of purses today! I've decided to NOT keep the Ali. I love her in pics and on others, just not on me. I like the Mandy a lot and would love to have her for a bigger bag that isn't a tote. My concern is cost of keeping her and the shoulder bag. I got great prices on them both, but not sure if it's the right thing for my budget. So, at this point the Mandy is a toss up. I'm going to list some more on eBay today and tomorrow and my Mandy decision will probably be based on how they sell!