Which YSL to buy? - Kate or Sunset?

Which YSL bag should I get?

  • YSL Kate Gold Hardware

    Votes: 36 36.7%

  • YSL Kate Croc Silver Hardware

    Votes: 36 36.7%

  • YSL Sunset Bag

    Votes: 28 28.6%
  • Total voters
    98

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Miss World

Miss World

O.G.
Nov 6, 2006
4,621
4,499
#1
Hi guys, I’m having a difficult time deciding which YSL bag to get.

I would like to use this bag for upcoming weddings but also casually on weekends or out to dinner.

The Sunset Medium is roomy and would fit all my essentials but I’m concerned it will look too bulky for night wear? But it would be such a practical bag for daytime or dinners.

The YSL Kate as always been on my Wishlist but I could never decide between the caviar leather with gold hardware or the crocodile embossed with silver hardware. Which look do you guys prefer?

Please help - YSL Sunset Medium or which Kate Bag? Thank you :)
 

Attachments

  • F3A8CDBF-7E44-4E0B-B121-E85933D47B6C.jpeg
    F3A8CDBF-7E44-4E0B-B121-E85933D47B6C.jpeg
    47.7 KB · Views: 545
  • B3E0E026-6F53-43D8-A252-553461CEB79D.jpeg
    B3E0E026-6F53-43D8-A252-553461CEB79D.jpeg
    426 KB · Views: 549
  • 3153B950-094D-41EB-B0FF-8BDC8E8C1246.jpeg
    3153B950-094D-41EB-B0FF-8BDC8E8C1246.jpeg
    356.2 KB · Views: 551
  • 4ED18ADD-93C0-4155-9501-E34FF692008E.jpeg
    4ED18ADD-93C0-4155-9501-E34FF692008E.jpeg
    421.7 KB · Views: 552
  • DDA6FFB0-331E-46D6-8556-836E6CDCB905.jpeg
    DDA6FFB0-331E-46D6-8556-836E6CDCB905.jpeg
    337.1 KB · Views: 541
  • Like
Reactions: Venessa84 and Strep2031
#2
Kate bag! It’s more elegant. And I agree with you, the sunset just looks bulky. Alternatively I would recommend the medium envelope because it’s truly classic & just stunning. But I know many people are having bad wear and tear issues with it. Mine, while two weeks “old” is great so far! Fingers crossed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: caroperouse and Miss World
#3
dorinda80 said:
Kate bag! It’s more elegant. And I agree with you, the sunset just looks bulky. Alternatively I would recommend the medium envelope because it’s truly classic & just stunning. But I know many people are having bad wear and tear issues with it. Mine, while two weeks “old” is great so far! Fingers crossed.
Click to expand...
Thank you Dorinda80. Envelope bag is also on my Wishlist but I think I’ll be getting the Large at some point. Which YSL Kate do you prefer? The classic black/gold or the semi-matte crocodile with brushed silver hardware?
 
#6
I agree with the others that the Sunset is too bulky for weddings and such outings. The medium Kate is a great size. Both the crocodile embossed with silver hardware and the classic black/gold are stunning. Do you wear more gold or silver jewelry? That could be a factor in deciding which one to pick.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JVSXOXO and Miss World
#7
Purses & Perfumes said:
I agree with the others that the Sunset is too bulky for weddings and such outings. The medium Kate is a great size. Both the crocodile embossed with silver hardware and the classic black/gold are stunning. Do you wear more gold or silver jewelry? That could be a factor in deciding which one to pick.
Click to expand...
Hi I don’t wear much jewellery so I don’t have an issue there, but when I do wear it it’s usually gold. I don’t mind mixing my metals though. However I would like a bag that goes with most outfits and versatile enough for day and night.
 
#8
Miss World said:
Hi I don’t wear much jewellery so I don’t have an issue there, but when I do wear it it’s usually gold. I don’t mind mixing my metals though. However I would like a bag that goes with most outfits and versatile enough for day and night.
Click to expand...
If you don't mind mixing your metals, then perhaps go with the silver/crocodile embossed one. I went with classic gold/black and I tend to use the bag mostly for less casual/evening outings. Its a difficult decision because they are both so beautiful!
 
#9
Purses & Perfumes said:
If you don't mind mixing your metals, then perhaps go with the silver/crocodile embossed one. I went with classic gold/black and I tend to use the bag mostly for less casual/evening outings. Its a difficult decision because they are both so beautiful!
Click to expand...
It’s definitely a tough decision for me. The gold one is so classic but the crocodile one is so very edgy and unique.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top