Which one to keep

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

i ordered 3 Rogue 36 from the outlet. The discount wasn’t great at all, only 50%off of the retail price. I want to keep only one and I’m having a hard time to decide with one to keep. I’m planning to return 2 and repurchase them when they are offered at a deeper discount. Honestly, every bag has issues. The olive one has an even color, hardware is scratched and the edge paint is cracking. The dark denim one came from a store and it doesn’t have any noticeable defects but I can tell that it was a floor model. The leather of the grey rogue is so smooth and you can see the handle prints on the bag. Despite all these defects I still want to keep one. So, which one would you keep if any?[/QUOT
I cant help bc i wAmt you to keep all
 
Thank you ladies! I think I’ll reorder a rogue in olive today and will return the other two. I feel like as soon as I decide to keep them, they will be offered at 70% off and I’ll will be feeling cheated by Coach again. It’s just too much money for the bags that not that perfect. I wish I kept a rogue 36 in demon from the winter sale. It was 50% off plus I had a friends and family code.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Greenandblue
Thank you ladies! I think I’ll reorder a rogue in olive today and will return the other two. I feel like as soon as I decide to keep them, they will be offered at 70% off and I’ll will be feeling cheated by Coach again. It’s just too much money for the bags that not that perfect. I wish I kept a rogue 36 in demon from the winter sale. It was 50% off plus I had a friends and family code.
I was just coming to post that the olive one is beautiful... just not in that condition. I think you are making the best choice by reordering that color!
 
I love both my denim and olive and want grey. So I am no help
I love all three colors but I do not want to have all of them at 50% off. I’ll repurchase them when coach will have a deeper discount. And honestly I want bags in better condition if I pay that much money. Today is my last day for a pa. I love this size and I want it in black, Oxblood and saddle.
 
I love all three colors but I do not want to have all of them at 50% off. I’ll repurchase them when coach will have a deeper discount. And honestly I want bags in better condition if I pay that much money. Today is my last day for a pa. I love this size and I want it in black, Oxblood and saddle.
Oxblood gone. All mine came from Jax. Whr did yours come from. I didnt even notice anything wrong with my olive but I usually don’t inspect like most. If its not where my eye catches i dont bother but i understand your concerns
 
Those indents will come out with use. I have switched to carrying my regular Rogues as shoulder bags and I tuck the handles on. After carrying one of mine for 4 weeks that way it had indents. I stuffed it with the handles out when I put it back in its dust bag and the indents are gone now.
 
Thank you ladies! I think I’ll reorder a rogue in olive today and will return the other two. I feel like as soon as I decide to keep them, they will be offered at 70% off and I’ll will be feeling cheated by Coach again. It’s just too much money for the bags that not that perfect. I wish I kept a rogue 36 in demon from the winter sale. It was 50% off plus I had a friends and family code.

If I remembered correctly, friends and family sale doesn’t apply to discounted items.
 
Part 1
Okay, here is my update:

This last Saturday I went to return two bags and surprisingly, the outlet had 70% discount on deletes. I was able to do a price adjustment for all three bags. The only thing that I’m still confused that the store manager was trying to tell me that they don’t do price adjustments on previously bought merchandise. If they don’t do price adjustment on the previous bought merchandise then when do they do price adjustments? Lol, it’s more of a retorical question. Anyway, the honored me 70%off instead of me having returned these bags because I said I don’t want to screw your numbers up but at the same time I’m here for my interest not yours. Okay, the discount is received. Here are my three bags and my total savings from the first purchase to the pa is $780 excluding taxes. I’m very happy about it
 

Attachments

  • 7755C5F1-422C-4A2B-B68A-6B3965D3D743.jpeg
    7755C5F1-422C-4A2B-B68A-6B3965D3D743.jpeg
    194 KB · Views: 133
Then I wanted to place a found order which they rejected. I called a different outlet and they gave a story that I’ll have to pay the full price for the retail bags. So, I called the corporation and they took my order over the phone for two more rogues: rogue 36 in saddle and black. I’m waiting for them to arrive this week. I would think for a normal person it would be more than enough but not for me. I admit I’m not normal and have some addiction issues when it comes to handbags but at the same time who misses deals like this? I’m so tired to pay full prices so this time I feel very satisfied and comfortable with the prices that I paid
 
Top