Could have been, I'm not sure. I'm starting to recognize the active members on the
Coach forum now but when I saw that post I had only been a lurker. In a way, K.E.W, one of your posts led me to join. I was debating buying the large punk rexy in black and white and I couldn't find photos or a review anywhere on the internet. I asked the Coach online assistants what size it was and they gave me 2 completely different answers. I finally found your photos on google and ended up reading the Rexy club posts / charm posts which helped me decide. Even though you returned yours, it was helpful to me to see the photos. But during my lurking and in search of reviews I got some good ideas (like double secure charm) and thought 'hey this seems like a cool forum maybe I'll join"