Which COACH bag are you carrying today?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

This was my second and I love her! I also love the olive!! Did you get a different one?
Yes, I took the one they had shipped in for me. In the meantime ordered the Melon to replace the Olive, but kept the Olive "just in case". The plan was to return the Olive when the Melon arrived. Melon doesn't get here til Thursday. So, that gives me the opportunity to change my mind multiple times. I think I set myself up for failure, didn't I? LOL
 
Yes, I took the one they had shipped in for me. In the meantime ordered the Melon to replace the Olive, but kept the Olive "just in case". The plan was to return the Olive when the Melon arrived. Melon doesn't get here til Thursday. So, that gives me the opportunity to change my mind multiple times. I think I set myself up for failure, didn't I? LOL
Lol! I think you set yourself up to have some amazing bags to carry!!!!
 
Did this one get away from you?
It was the first Rogue I bought, and I loved it. The second day I used it, the hardware started peeling. I was so sad/upset. I called my store, and they immediately said I could return it. They were all sold out by then, so I "settled" for the marine. (I love and I'm glad I have it.) I still think of chalk often. [emoji57]
 
Twins! I have to say that this is my first and favorite of my Rogues. Btw, I'm contemplating keeping the Olive again. Ahhh! [emoji28]
I've decided to keep olive too. I left it unwrapped so every time I walked into my "purse room" I could see both the olive and the blue suede lining and decided I had to keep it.
I was originally comparing it to butterscotch and black Prussian and that's why olive underwhelmed me. Comparing it to black or saddle made me realize it's a keeper.
Also, I think my original indecisiveness was because it's better as a fall color and right now it's 90F in sunny Florida.
 
I've decided to keep olive too. I left it unwrapped so every time I walked into my "purse room" I could see both the olive and the blue suede lining and decided I had to keep it.
I was originally comparing it to butterscotch and black Prussian and that's why olive underwhelmed me. Comparing it to black or saddle made me realize it's a keeper.
Also, I think my original indecisiveness was because it's better as a fall color and right now it's 90F in sunny Florida.

I liked my Olive from start (sure, not as vibrant as my Butterscotch or as playful as my Whiplash, but she is classy). I even bought her at FP (but did get a PA when price dropped, luckily!).

For some of you though it sounds like Olive is like a friend you never really even think of dating, then one day you wake up and realize you had fallen in love ha ha. Glad to hear some of you are holding onto her after all!

I am not really carrying any of my Rogues much this time of year as in the summer I gravitate towards smaller, lighter, hand carries and crossbodies. But that does not stop me thinking the Rogues are still the perfect bag. I just love their versatility and comfort. I only have the three, but I love seeing them all there waiting for me to bring them out come fall when I will swing them back on my shoulder again!

Now if only my Rogue 25 would show up - I can definitely see carrying that this time of year!
 
Top