Chanel inimitable is by far the best I've tried. No clumps, contact safe, and dont make my lashes brittle and stiff. one thing I love about chanels, it's more of a natural look. I'm loving the LE jade green color they have out in the summer collection.
I didn't care for Diorshow, or the unlimited but, I did like the black out, espically for my nights outs. Blackout is my second fav. MAC Zoom is also working well with me, which is very suprising. so, who knows that may be my third fav.