What bag should I get??? HELP!!

#1 and #3 have my vote! #1 is more a spring/summer bag and the color is so fun! and #3 I love the khaki optic and the style of the bag so much!
 
I like #1. I hate to say this because we all know how we feel about fakes.

Sorry I don't understand. # 1 is not a fake the pic is directly from the coach website.

My apologies I didn't mean to cause any confusion. You are right #1 is not a fake, and I know that too. It is my most favorite C fabric. Unfortunately, though there are a just a lot of fakes being made with this optic fabric. It has swayed me away from C bags in general.
 
my sister has #1 in black. while it's a nice bag overall, I don't like the pebbled texture of the leather. Reminds me of old-lady bags. I absolutely LOVE #2! It's number 1 on my wish list. I do really like #4 as well.