It’s ok. I didn’t realize that because I was never good in math.
I’ll definitely try something locally after your suggestion!
Wedding Band Dilemma
- Thread starter marialc121
- Start date
TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others
It’s ok. I didn’t realize that because I was never good in math.
I’ll definitely try something locally after your suggestion!
I got to try on a few bands today. What do u guys think?
This band is the first one in my post. The two below are other bands that I tried on today.
This band is the first one in my post. The two below are other bands that I tried on today.
marialc121, you have really good taste in rings! All three of these options are really pretty. That said, the third is my favorite; so here is my slightly biased opinion of each:
The first one is elegant and classic. It appears to be an exact match to your wedding set, while showcasing a flawless example of metal mixing.
The second one is an eye-catcher. When I first saw the photo I thought that you had put three rings together to make a five ring stack. After reanalyzing I concluded that it is probably just one ring. With most designs, I would probably think that the width of the second option is too wide in comparison to your wedding set; however, since it can appear to be three ring, I think it looks like an eye-catching ring stack. While this is my least favorite of the three, it is still quite beautiful.
The third one is an example of perfection! (Ok, I warned you that I was biased.) I like the fact that the pink gold band is wider than the white metal bands since there are two of the white metal bands and only one of the pink gold. I also really like the look of these two different diamond settings together. The third is a unique ring stack that blends together perfectly. Another flawless example of metal (and diamond setting) mixing.
All three examples are gorgeous! Which one looks and feels the best to you?
The first one is elegant and classic. It appears to be an exact match to your wedding set, while showcasing a flawless example of metal mixing.
The second one is an eye-catcher. When I first saw the photo I thought that you had put three rings together to make a five ring stack. After reanalyzing I concluded that it is probably just one ring. With most designs, I would probably think that the width of the second option is too wide in comparison to your wedding set; however, since it can appear to be three ring, I think it looks like an eye-catching ring stack. While this is my least favorite of the three, it is still quite beautiful.
The third one is an example of perfection! (Ok, I warned you that I was biased.) I like the fact that the pink gold band is wider than the white metal bands since there are two of the white metal bands and only one of the pink gold. I also really like the look of these two different diamond settings together. The third is a unique ring stack that blends together perfectly. Another flawless example of metal (and diamond setting) mixing.
All three examples are gorgeous! Which one looks and feels the best to you?
Thank you so much for your kind words and feedback!
I also appreciate you for taking the time to analyze each band with my wedding set. It is definitely very useful and gives me a better perspective of what I want.
I love both the first and third one! The second one is beautiful but better worn alone.
As for the first band, I think it’s more subtle and showcases my engagement ring, whereas, I love how the third band looks different from my current rings and makes my wedding set more interesting.
My DH likes the first one because he likes simple designs.
I’m torn between both now!
I prefer the first option: very beautiful, a subtle difference but still noticable enough. Also the main focus remains on your engamentring. I like the third too, but somehow the first makes more sense and looks more balanced. The third looks more like an afterthought, adding another ring, the first looks meant to be somehow. Let us know what you pick!
Ps and what a gorgeous set it already is!!
Ps and what a gorgeous set it already is!!
I would definitely put a considerable amount of weight on your husband's opinion. Chances are, he knows you better than anyone else.
I was also able to think of one advantage that the first option has. Since it is the thinnest ring, it leaves the most finger room for future additions.
I was also able to think of one advantage that the first option has. Since it is the thinnest ring, it leaves the most finger room for future additions.
Thank you for your feedback and for your compliments on my set!
Thank you! I’m the opposite and prefer not to be match matchy but I love the first band because like you said, it puts focus on my ering and may be more timeless.
I would definitely put a considerable amount of weight on your husband's opinion. Chances are, he knows you better than anyone else.
I was also able to think of one advantage that the first option has. Since it is the thinnest ring, it leaves the most finger room for future additions.
My DH is not really good with design or jewelry so most of the time he will get my opinion on what I want.
But in this case, it’s an anniversary present and he wanted to add a band to my set to represent our DS, whom I gave birth to last year.I also love the idea of being able to add more in the future!
Good thinking! 
If you ask me, I say the third one. Not sure which one you chose but I'm sure you can't go wrong
If you ask me, I say the third one. Not sure which one you chose but I'm sure you can't go wrong
Thank you!
I have not gotten the band yet. It’s such a tough decision for me!Thank you so much!
I agree! I keep going back and forth on the first and third band.