
Thank you!
Yes, I agree MOP and chalcedony are too close. That is the reason why I do not have a chalcedony set. I have tried on chalcedony several times thinking I would get the set, but it looks too close to MOP, so I pass. But... that's because I wear only 20s, unlike you who also wears 10s.
My thoughts if I may...
I love blue agate, and if you wear YG, it's beautiful. I tried to order a blue agate set back in Nov 2021, and all pieces were approved (e.g. VA earrings, 20 motif, bracelet) except for the 20 motif which is the base for my set. Hence, I passed because I didn't want just earrings and bracelets.
If you wear YG and love blue agate, I say go for it! It's beautiful; the stone is absolutely stunning and pops. However, it seems you are unsure because it is YG.
Here are some thoughts that might help you decide...
1) Blue agate and YG in that necklace will come across very "yellow." This is because YG is already yellow, and the blue agate hue VCA uses has a drop of yellow in it, which makes it very warm (vs. a drop of red in the blue agate which would make it cool). This is different than say, onyx with YG, or MOP with YG, as these stones do not have "yellow" in them.
Hence, the blue agate necklace will be a very "yellow and warm" necklace.
2) From what I have been told, VCA will no longer make blue agate earrings, even via SO. My SA said they received too many complaints from past SOs on blue agate earrings (e.g. too translucent, the hue did not match their other pieces), so VCA stopped. Think about what other jewelry you plan to wear with it this blue agate 20 as well as what outfits.
If you are ok with the two above and have other pieces to wear with it, I say go for it!
If not, and you are only choosing from what's available because you are itching to buy a 20, for me, I would wait.
I am a white metal gal, so only platinum or WG for me. I know myself, and no matter how much I love blue agate, if it's YG, I might wear it a few times and not truly feel great when I wear it.
I am not sure if you know this, but VCA is coming out with WG guilloche this fall. It's a lot of shiny metal, so you might not like it, but I wanted to share that with you as an option. I'm not sure if it's coming out in a 20 though, but my SA told me it's coming and he knows I like 20s, so my guess is yes.
This brings me back full circle to you...
Since your chalcedony is a 10, a WG MOP in a 20 is a different look, so that's something to consider. I didn't purchase both as I only wear 20s, but you also wear 10s. For me, if I had your combo, I would get the WG MOP 20 and matching earrings. It's a different look with your chalcedony 10 and earrings.
I personally do not like warm metal (e.g. YG or RG) against skin. I like cool metal (platinum or WG) that pops, as you can see in my photo. My ring is in platinum and I love the coolness of platinum. That's just me though, and I know everyone has their preferences.
I hope this was helpful, and good luck in your decision!
Dear @BigAkoya, I am so grateful for your wisdom and guidance. You are too right about the yellow gold, I definitely prefer the white gold. Thanks again for keeping me in line, it seems you know my mind better than myself
Last edited: