VCA ~ Van Cleef Arpels Discussion thread!

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Hi,
I am trying to pick Magic malachite earrings for my mom. I asked my SA for dark stone with lot of striations and my SA sent me these 3 options. Should I pick one of these or ask for other options? As a Malachite newbie, I am not aware how dark the stone would be and also if I should pick a medium tone since the stone will darken with time. Thanks!
Option 1
View attachment 4646019

Option 2
View attachment 4646025

Option 3
View attachment 4646026
My preference is in this order: #3, #1, and #2
I believe your mother will be very happy with malachite, it is such a beautiful stone.
 
Has anyone had problems lately with their earrings? I bought a pair of small Frivole and after wearing two days, one of the posts came off and I almost lost the earring. My SA exchanged them for another pair and the same thing just happened again. I wore that pair probably 3 times. I’ve worn my mini Frivole for two years straight with no problems.
 

Attachments

  • 4A748422-1B61-47A3-82F2-5990C774A23F.jpeg
    4A748422-1B61-47A3-82F2-5990C774A23F.jpeg
    83 KB · Views: 399
Has anyone had problems lately with their earrings? I bought a pair of small Frivole and after wearing two days, one of the posts came off and I almost lost the earring. My SA exchanged them for another pair and the same thing just happened again. I wore that pair probably 3 times. I’ve worn my mini Frivole for two years straight with no problems.
I also had that happened with pave frivole. I was told they are meant to be clips and the post can just screw in. I requested to put them permanently and they sent them out, took a couple of weeks. Another pair I bought prior to that was fine.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Phoenix123
Has anyone had problems lately with their earrings? I bought a pair of small Frivole and after wearing two days, one of the posts came off and I almost lost the earring. My SA exchanged them for another pair and the same thing just happened again. I wore that pair probably 3 times. I’ve worn my mini Frivole for two years straight with no problems.

This happened to my LE Onyx earrings a few times. I got fed up and requested to have the posts soldered on.
 
Top