Van Cleef in action!

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

I’ve never worn these together although I do combine blue and black a lot in other contexts and decided to try it out running errands today. I thought I’d give a Magic pendant a chance and was pretty shocked at the color difference. They were purchased a few years apart and I’ve never tried to wear them together because i wear the magic so little so I’d never noticed they basically look like different stones. I’d read about this in other threads before but was still surprised to see it. Another strike against the magic, maybe. Certainly don’t see myself wearing it with the BA 5!

View attachment 5377590

View attachment 5377591
I love the shade of blue of your magic :love:
 
  • Like
Reactions: DS2006 and DeryaHm
I love the shade of blue of your magic :love:

Thank you! The color is beautiful but I feel like a cross between a billboard for VCA, a disco personality, and my grandmothers, both of whom used to wear long pendants when I actually wear it. This is one of the few pieces I picked myself and just *had* to have but I just never seem to be comfortable with it. I wish I could remember what I was wearing when I tried it on because that did make me smile big and glowingly happy. I’m a little on the fence about selling, DH is very against, and I need to track down the COA anyway, so I’m trying to give it some chances in the meantime. I’m sorry it doesn’t work with my bracelet, which I love. Oh well
 
I’ve never worn these together although I do combine blue and black a lot in other contexts and decided to try it out running errands today. I thought I’d give a Magic pendant a chance and was pretty shocked at the color difference. They were purchased a few years apart and I’ve never tried to wear them together because i wear the magic so little so I’d never noticed they basically look like different stones. I’d read about this in other threads before but was still surprised to see it. Another strike against the magic, maybe. Certainly don’t see myself wearing it with the BA 5!

View attachment 5377590

View attachment 5377591
Yes blue agate can vary so much. I like the blue and black together. Nice way to wear blue agate in the ‘winter’.
 
Thank you! The color is beautiful but I feel like a cross between a billboard for VCA, a disco personality, and my grandmothers, both of whom used to wear long pendants when I actually wear it. This is one of the few pieces I picked myself and just *had* to have but I just never seem to be comfortable with it. I wish I could remember what I was wearing when I tried it on because that did make me smile big and glowingly happy. I’m a little on the fence about selling, DH is very against, and I need to track down the COA anyway, so I’m trying to give it some chances in the meantime. I’m sorry it doesn’t work with my bracelet, which I love. Oh well
What are your favorite pieces and easiest to wear pieces? Maybe we can come up with some ideas for you of how to wear it that suit your style. It really is a stunning necklace.
 
What are your favorite pieces and easiest to wear pieces? Maybe we can come up with some ideas for you of how to wear it that suit your style. It really is a stunning necklace.

I’m thinking part of what bothers me is the juxtaposition of the logo and the fact that the magic pendant, in particular, just feels costume-y to me because of how light the motif is and how tall the loop on top is and how it slides around. I don’t like any of my magic pieces really, but I do find this one especially irritating because the blue is beautiful and this is one of a very few pieces I chose for myself and felt like I really had to have.

I wonder how it would be to really lean into the costume-y feel and wear it with something like giant Jennifer Fisher hoops or, if I can find them, these again very oversized and costume-y lapis and thin wire teardrop hoops from the moma shop.

Weirdly I find it very easy to wear most of my “real” jewelry and feel self conscious in costume, so maybe that’s part of it. It also occurs to me that I could dig around in some of the casual yg pieces I inherited from my MIL and lean into the 70s vibe.
 
  • Like
Reactions: missie1 and hhw
I’m thinking part of what bothers me is the juxtaposition of the logo and the fact that the magic pendant, in particular, just feels costume-y to me because of how light the motif is and how tall the loop on top is and how it slides around. I don’t like any of my magic pieces really, but I do find this one especially irritating because the blue is beautiful and this is one of a very few pieces I chose for myself and felt like I really had to have.

I wonder how it would be to really lean into the costume-y feel and wear it with something like giant Jennifer Fisher hoops or, if I can find them, these again very oversized and costume-y lapis and thin wire teardrop hoops from the moma shop.

Weirdly I find it very easy to wear most of my “real” jewelry and feel self conscious in costume, so maybe that’s part of it. It also occurs to me that I could dig around in some of the casual yg pieces I inherited from my MIL and lean into the 70s vibe.
I don’t wear pendants. They have never been me and if I do wear them I layer. But if you want to embrace this piece I would try it short doubled with gold thick hoop earrings (the hallow ones) and pair with lower neckline dress or vneck shirt (could do a plain white button shirt with rolled up sleeves with jeans). Then toss on your blue and black bracelets and voila!
 
  • Like
Reactions: missie1 and DeryaHm
I’m thinking part of what bothers me is the juxtaposition of the logo and the fact that the magic pendant, in particular, just feels costume-y to me because of how light the motif is and how tall the loop on top is and how it slides around. I don’t like any of my magic pieces really, but I do find this one especially irritating because the blue is beautiful and this is one of a very few pieces I chose for myself and felt like I really had to have.

I wonder how it would be to really lean into the costume-y feel and wear it with something like giant Jennifer Fisher hoops or, if I can find them, these again very oversized and costume-y lapis and thin wire teardrop hoops from the moma shop.

Weirdly I find it very easy to wear most of my “real” jewelry and feel self conscious in costume, so maybe that’s part of it. It also occurs to me that I could dig around in some of the casual yg pieces I inherited from my MIL and lean into the 70s vibe.
I do think the length of the chain paired with the size of the motif makes styling more difficult. For me, it falls to almost waist length worn long, which seems a bit awkward for a pendant, I just see a big belly button. I also see what you are saying; that with the long chain and big pendant, it is almost like an 80’s/90’s medallion. Maybe go for a cooler decade with big pendants and try 70s. Maybe try a damask print top and a gold cuff bracelet. Perhaps similar to styling to what would work for the zodiac pendants.
I am not a pendant person, so I don’t love it doubled in a typical pendant length. I have seen some photos online of ladies who somehow achieved a mid-length where the pendant hits about at the sternum and I think that is ideal for this larger sized pendant. I am not sure how they achieved this. Perhaps moved the jump ring? Or some wizardry with the chain looped behind the neck?
 
Have you tried these yet??? I honestly LOVE them if they'd work with the shape of your others. I definitely like them more than the ones at Tiffany. I'd be very interested to know if they work with VCA bangles.



Good idea! I will have to text Briony and make an appointment with her, too.

Aside from the Perlee, Perle d'Or, there's the Sweet Clover Bracelet . . .
Perlée sweet clovers bracelet, medium model, Rose gold, Diamond:  40 stones,  0.69 carat, Three Fourth, Jewelry Bracelet
Perlée pearls of gold bracelet, medium model, Rose gold, Three Fourth, Jewelry Bracelet

I forgot about this! Thank you!
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: DS2006, 880 and hhw
I’ve never worn these together although I do combine blue and black a lot in other contexts and decided to try it out running errands today. I thought I’d give a Magic pendant a chance and was pretty shocked at the color difference. They were purchased a few years apart and I’ve never tried to wear them together because i wear the magic so little so I’d never noticed they basically look like different stones. I’d read about this in other threads before but was still surprised to see it. Another strike against the magic, maybe. Certainly don’t see myself wearing it with the BA 5!

View attachment 5377590

View attachment 5377591


Ok, @Safa - once again I am being the weirdo because I would wear these together even though the colors are not the same. I love both shades of blue and I like all three together. The colors are different enough that it looks like they’re different on purpose. And I love that you have them both with that pretty green.

I didn’t wear pendants before I got the Magic. And to be perfectly honest, I have had it for several years and not once have I worn it long. I always, always wear the chain doubled, and usually on the jump ring, too, depending on the neckline and what I’m wearing. I think the chain doubled looks better, too (visually its just the right width to balance the size of the pendant). And really, when it’s that far away from your wrist, I think it probably works just fine.

But if you dont like or expect to wear the Magic, you might as well just let it go.
 
Last edited:
Here’s to staying mentally strong, I love all of this! Here’s my current struggle: my only luxury purchase I am making this year is the diamond JUC (not pave) for my golden birthday (turning 28 on August 28). We are going to Vegas to celebrate but my struggle is that my VCA SA also knows it’ll be my birthday and wants to plan something special for me. Yes I have a lot of VCA on my wishlist but comfortably I only wanted to buy the JUC this year. I don’t want to feel pressured into buying something at VCA if he is planning something special but how do you walk away empty handed after that?? I will need to reevaluate what I should do here ugh.
It’s not a quid pro quo. Many premier designers do this. VCA once served a special caviar and smoked salmon spread for us. We turned it down bc I don’t like to eat or drink when trying on, nor do I want to feel obligated for something I didn’t ask for. They did suggest I try on a bunch of things after I expressed a simple interest in learning about different lines. that included a 5 million dollar emerald piece that they knew in no way was I ever going to purchase (bc I told them so). They also included a Romeo and Juliette piece and a liane in the line up, and we met the regional manager (we knew her sister from another premier luxury brand so knew she would be there too). none of the pieces worked, but I considered the liane for many months. while we appreciated the gesture, there was no obligation. VCA also knows there is always another occasion :smile: happy birthday!
 
Last edited:
Thank you! The color is beautiful but I feel like a cross between a billboard for VCA, a disco personality, and my grandmothers, both of whom used to wear long pendants when I actually wear it. This is one of the few pieces I picked myself and just *had* to have but I just never seem to be comfortable with it. I wish I could remember what I was wearing when I tried it on because that did make me smile big and glowingly happy. I’m a little on the fence about selling, DH is very against, and I need to track down the COA anyway, so I’m trying to give it some chances in the meantime. I’m sorry it doesn’t work with my bracelet, which I love. Oh well
I see this with a white cotton sundress and gold earrings.
 
It’s not a quid pro quo. Many premier designers do this. VCA once served a special caviar and smoked salmon canapé spread for us. We turned it down bc I don’t like to eat or drink when trying on, nor do I want to feel obligated for something I didn’t ask for. They did suggest I try on a bunch of things after I expressed a simple interest in learning about different lines. that included a 5 million dollar emerald piece that they knew in no way was I ever going to purchase (bc I told them so). They also included a Romeo and Juliette piece and a liane in the line up, and we met the regional manager (we knew her sister from another premier luxury brand so knew she would be there too). none of the pieces worked, but I considered the liane for many months. while we appreciated the gesture, there was no obligation. VCA also knows there is always another occasion :smile: happy birthday!

Thank you so much for sharing your experience! I have told him many times as well that my fiancé and I do not drink, period, and I thought to myself what would he offer us? Diet Coke? Lol. But your experience sounded lavish to say the least!
 
Ok, @Safa - once again I am being the weirdo because I would wear these together even though the colors are not the same. I love both shades of blue and I like all three together. The colors are different enough that it looks like they’re different on purpose. And I love that you have them both with that pretty green.

I didn’t wear pendants before I got the Magic. And to be perfectly honest, I have had it for several years and not once have I worn it long. I always, always wear the chain doubled, and usually on the jump ring, too, depending on the neckline and what I’m wearing. I think the chain doubled looks better, too (visually its just the right width to balance the size of the pendant). And really, when it’s that far away from your wrist, I think it probably works just fine.

But if you dont like or expect to wear the Magic, you might as well just let it go.

I'm going to experiment with ways to shorten the chain today. DH doesn't get involved if I sell old bags or buy bags, but I think because in our culture women keep gold (not VCA style, like coins, bars, plain bracelets) to sell in an emergency he has a bad association with selling. He of course wouldn't stop me, but I don't want to make him feel bad! No rush, though, I'll play around with it a bit. I did try some (non-BA) magic earrings on and those may have to go.
 
Top