Urgent Help - Picotin 18 vs 22 suitable for my build!

[Addicted to bags]

I vote for the 22 on you but that may be more based on the color.

I have both sizes, my 18 is in the Maurice leather which is less slouchy than Clemence. No changes in shape.
I use a Mai Tai insert in my 22 (which is in Clemence) so I don't see any changes in shape in the 22 either.

 

[kl7]

+1 18

 

[bagshopr]

22!

 

[maxroxxherhandbags]

I agree with @baileylab the 22 elongates you the 18 just looks too small especially if you were to wear it with a coat or jacket.

 

[WhiteBus]

I think the 18 looks silly

 

[Ykie]

Thanks everyone for sharing your views. Do u all own a picotin and how does picotin age when slouchy? Will it look bigger n longer when slouchy or somehow appear smaller?

 

[Suncatcher]

I really prefer the 22 on you.

 

[DAMER]

I personally prefer 22 on you as well

 

[Maedi]

I like the 22 black on you.

 

[caruava]

Personally I feel there is space for both. They are both great sizes. I like a pop in the smaller and a more neutral for errands in the larger. Both suit you very well and lucky you.

I prefer the 22 on you.

 

[Ykie]

Dear TPF-ers, thanks for sharing your views. I will be getting Etoupe but still very undecided on 18 vs 22

 

[Naessi]

Dear TPF-ers, thanks for sharing your views. I will be getting Etoupe but still very undecided on 18 vs 22

Are you able to try etoupe in the two different sizes? Whenever I have tried picos (but still undecided on colour and size so haven't bought any yet) I find that the colour has quite an impact on how the different sizes are perceived.

If I had to choose one I'd choose 18 in etoupe for you (22 if you were going for black), but ultimately, go for the one you think you will enjoy the most.

 

[Ykie]

Untir

Are you able to try etoupe in the two different sizes? Whenever I have tried picos (but still undecided on colour and size so haven't bought any yet) I find that the colour has quite an impact on how the different sizes are perceived.

If I had to choose one I'd choose 18 in etoupe for you (22 if you were going for black), but ultimately, go for the one you think you will enjoy the most.

Unfortunately I wasn’t able to compare for the same Color in different sizes. Else that will be easier. Is there any reason why u think bigger size for the darker Color?

 

[jimmyshoogirl]

You’ve selected the color. You clearly like both sizes or you wouldn’t be considering them both. At this point you just have to make a decision and stick with it and don’t overthink it. Choose the one you know you will use the most, not what’s the most popular.

22 looks best on you.

 

[Ykie]

You’ve selected the color. You clearly like both sizes or you wouldn’t be considering them both. At this point you just have to make a decision and stick with it and don’t overthink it. Choose the one you know you will use the most, not what’s the most popular.

Agree. The most difficult part is to nail down the size…. I only had 1 chance to get the bag before my SA leaves hence I want to make sure I won’t regret or sell whichever size I want. I have been scrolling through many videos and photos to see the sizes