Edited...woops I guess reading all the posts helps!
I think that if you can return the Tacori if you don't like it that you should go that route.
Also check out SignedPieces.com and click on Facets Collection. They have tons of gorgeous bands.
Funny thing is DH surprised me with the Trio set from Facets, but I thought it was too much bling. I felt like all those diamonds (which were better in color than mine) out did my center stone. It was just too much for me, so we put the diamond back in my tulip setting. Here's a picture of those rings. (It must seem like I'm a difficult brat. lol) But my jeweler messed up my original wedding band (which was very sentimental to me) a few years ago and I haven't worn a wedding band since. Anyhow, maybe I could do an eternity band by itself. Oh and the Tacori band can be returned if I don't like it. I've tried them on in person before too.