Update after wearing my Toms a couple times. I'm glad I went for the 6.5 versus the 7. One foot is bigger than the other and the slightly smaller foot fits perfectly. The slightly larger foot still feels a bit tight, especially in the toes, but I'm hoping it will stretch out more. I think the 7s would have flopped on my foot too much and drove me crazy. Normally if I'm in between sizes, I prefer the larger size, but not with these. I'm not sure I'd buy another pair just because getting a good fit doesn't seem to be very easy for me, but we'll have to see. I kind of regret getting the natural color because I think they're going to get dirty really easily.