Tiffany Soleste Earrings or VCA small lotus?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Another vote for the VCA earrings! And, I like the look of one (or two) dressy pieces of jewelry with casual clothes~ I'm wearing my VCA WG 10 motif necklace with a white tank and denim cutoffs today~ AND, I'm almost 37 weeks preggo so I'm HUGE! haha
 
this is a hard one!! I love the soleste earrings, but the VCA is just so feminine and even dainty looking, they are both amazing pairs of earrings but if I had to choose just one it would be the VCA lotus earrings, the modelling pic of calisnoopy convinces me that they are wearable with casual and formal attire, btw I love how she wears her jewellery she can layer and wear gorgeous high end designers without ever looking like the clothes or jewellery are wearing her :D
 
I think the VCA is more wearable as an everyday item as well. They feel more classic. And I also like them more. I say if you must get one, get the VCA. However, I do think you might be making a rush decision because of the price increases. Were you planning on getting earrings in the next few months anyway, or is this an impulse buy? There is always (espeically this year) going to be another price increase on the horizon and you just got your beautiful pendant so I would just take a time out and figure out which one you really love (although it sounds like VCA). If you got one, would you still be lusting after the other one?

Somewhat OT but - can you get discounts on VCA items in this price range? I know you definitely can't get discounts on the Tiffany but if you could finagle something on the VCA, it might even the playing field/put you a little more at ease about price increases.


Thank you everyone! It looks like you are all leaning the way I'm leaning - towards the VCA. Am thrilled to hear that you agree that they can be worn with jeans or formal wear (Thank you Eva and Calisnoopy!!)

Hmmmm... I'm going to have to do some research with my SA's today and see what the price increase deal is with the VCA. If it's 10% or less on them I might save up.

Thank you acrowcounted... I do think sometimes I need a kick in the behind! Is this an impulse buy? Let's say I didn't necessarily go in looking for earrings yesterday, have always lusted after the vca ones but kind of considered them out of price range until I mentally traded the soleste ring for the earrings yesterday, and then started to wonder what else I could get if I were to blow $10K... then it suddenly seemed like they were in reach in that bizarre self-enabling way we have! LOL. Yes the price increase is a fire under the butt... but 10% isn't enough to make me leap just yet if that's the case. I'll call Birks and VCA now and see what's what!

No I don't think I'd be lusting after the soleste if I got the VCA, those are my grail earrings... I tried them on at Birks once and almost died! I thought I wasn't an earring girl but am LOVING my studs and so happy I got those! So now considering a bit more bling! :)

I'm pretty sure VCA won't discount but I could probably apply for the birks card and get interest free payments...

and you're right, I JUST got my gorgeous pendant! Feeling a bit spoiled... ahhhh!

Well I THINK I've decided to go VCA if I go at all... I agree they are so blingy and feminine and not too big for me... the next decision is when!

And then I'm majorly seriously BANNED!
 
Girl! I think you need to walk away from the web for a bit. You've gotten a lot of GORGEOUS things in the last six months, a LOVE bracelet, a Solesete pendant, your diamond studs, and I think your ER upgrade was only a few months before that. And your VCA necklaces were last year too, right?

I know you can afford it, but have you really taken the time to enjoy the new stuff you've gotten? Those are a lot of really amazing pieces.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Juda
I would get the VCA. And wear hem every day with every thing! I LOVE fancy earrings for every day! I wear my diamond studs every day (though not as formal as these) but love to wear very formal earrings with my jeans.
 
I think the VCA is more wearable as an everyday item as well. They feel more classic. And I also like them more. I say if you must get one, get the VCA. However, I do think you might be making a rush decision because of the price increases. Were you planning on getting earrings in the next few months anyway, or is this an impulse buy? There is always (espeically this year) going to be another price increase on the horizon and you just got your beautiful pendant so I would just take a time out and figure out which one you really love (although it sounds like VCA). If you got one, would you still be lusting after the other one?

Somewhat OT but - can you get discounts on VCA items in this price range? I know you definitely can't get discounts on the Tiffany but if you could finagle something on the VCA, it might even the playing field/put you a little more at ease about price increases.

Girl! I think you need to walk away from the web for a bit. You've gotten a lot of GORGEOUS things in the last six months, a LOVE bracelet, a Solesete pendant, your diamond studs, and I think your ER upgrade was only a few months before that. And your VCA necklaces were last year too, right?

I know you can afford it, but have you really taken the time to enjoy the new stuff you've gotten? Those are a lot of really amazing pieces.

LOL... I'm going to read this all weekend before I make any moves. You are very right!!!! I think I do need to step away from the web a bit... even this site, it's giving me too many ideas!!! :p
 
Girl! I think you need to walk away from the web for a bit. You've gotten a lot of GORGEOUS things in the last six months, a LOVE bracelet, a Solesete pendant, your diamond studs, and I think your ER upgrade was only a few months before that. And your VCA necklaces were last year too, right?

I know you can afford it, but have you really taken the time to enjoy the new stuff you've gotten? Those are a lot of really amazing pieces.

Sound advice.

But, err, now I want the small lotus earrings too!:laugh:
 
Okay don't kill me lanasyogamama (LOL!) but the fates are totally aligning and telling me to get those VCA lotus earrings!

Just called my lovely SA in Naples and got the low down. They are currently $12,400. As of July 1st they'll be $14,000!! That's about 15% or $1,600... no small potatoes! Somehow that just totally breaks my comfort barrier going over 12 and into the teens. (scary how high this barrier has risen in 2 years - gah!)

This is the SA who sold me the breast cancer magic pendant and a few other things... anyway, I mentioned that I'd always regretted the magic pendant as it's just too big for me and I literally have not worn it yet... and it turns out she has been kicking herself for not buying it since it is a limited edition (she's also had a few clients inquire after it)... so she spoke to her manager and he is letting me exchange it against the lotus (I'd asked earlier if I could exchange for a 5 motif bracelet and he'd said no)!!

SO that brings the price down for me to $9,400!! $200 less than the Tiffany ones would be! AND FL sales tax is 7% I think... in Canada it's 14%.

I think I have to get them! I'll put them away (really!) in the safe for my 10th wedding anniversary in a few years, I don't care... this seems like too good an opportunity to pass up!
 
Okay don't kill me lanasyogamama (LOL!) but the fates are totally aligning and telling me to get those VCA lotus earrings!

Just called my lovely SA in Naples and got the low down. They are currently $12,400. As of July 1st they'll be $14,000!! That's about 15% or $1,600... no small potatoes! Somehow that just totally breaks my comfort barrier going over 12 and into the teens. (scary how high this barrier has risen in 2 years - gah!)

This is the SA who sold me the breast cancer magic pendant and a few other things... anyway, I mentioned that I'd always regretted the magic pendant as it's just too big for me and I literally have not worn it yet... and it turns out she has been kicking herself for not buying it since it is a limited edition (she's also had a few clients inquire after it)... so she spoke to her manager and he is letting me exchange it against the lotus (I'd asked earlier if I could exchange for a 5 motif bracelet and he'd said no)!!

SO that brings the price down for me to $9,400!! $200 less than the Tiffany ones would be! AND FL sales tax is 7% I think... in Canada it's 14%.

I think I have to get them! I'll put them away (really!) in the safe for my 10th wedding anniversary in a few years, I don't care... this seems like too good an opportunity to pass up!
that's great news! and even if you do put them away and not wear them for a while it's deinfitely worth it because in a few years I bet the same lotus earrings will be 16K or even 18K!!!

also at the same time you dont have any guilt for buying the magic because it will go towards credit for your lovely earrings and the magic will be out of your jewellery box and the guilt for buying a piece you nver wore will have vanished:cool: and magically turned into gorgeous sparkly earrings!
 
that's great news! and even if you do put them away and not wear them for a while it's deinfitely worth it because in a few years I bet the same lotus earrings will be 16K or even 18K!!!

also at the same time you dont have any guilt for buying the magic because it will go towards credit for your lovely earrings and the magic will be out of your jewellery box and the guilt for buying a piece you nver wore will have vanished:cool: and magically turned into gorgeous sparkly earrings!

Candice I can't wait to meet you in person - you think just like me! HAHA! It's like getting them for 30% off ! LOL... see my husband would absolutely cringe at this logic as I've paid for the magic already but I was thinking of listing it on ebay to put towards these earrings anyway and you're so right, I hate seeing that beautiful piece in my box as I just know that as much as I appreciate it, it's just too big for me... I never choose it! And it KILLS me b/c it was like $3200 or something. This way it goes to good use and I'm only out of pocket ("only" ... geeze) $9400! :)

I think you're right too... they are only going to go up in price and I'll never have an opportunity like this again... OFFICIALLY BANNED. That's IT!

But looking forward to lunch!!! Maybe Contessa will come too! :)
 
Candice I can't wait to meet you in person - you think just like me! HAHA! It's like getting them for 30% off ! LOL... see my husband would absolutely cringe at this logic as I've paid for the magic already but I was thinking of listing it on ebay to put towards these earrings anyway and you're so right, I hate seeing that beautiful piece in my box as I just know that as much as I appreciate it, it's just too big for me... I never choose it! And it KILLS me b/c it was like $3200 or something. This way it goes to good use and I'm only out of pocket ("only" ... geeze) $9400! :)

I think you're right too... they are only going to go up in price and I'll never have an opportunity like this again... OFFICIALLY BANNED. That's IT!

But looking forward to lunch!!! Maybe Contessa will come too! :)
haha we are both logically illogical???:laugh:
I just msged back to neverenoughbags, in a few days i'll start a thread to see who is available to meet in TO. i'm so excited we can all get together and put faces to the names :D
 
Top