I finally got my small black Sutton from Macy's. Hubby is so sweet,he said I should keep both (black and navy) but the colors are too close. This is hard, I love them both [emoji17]
I would keep both since it's being discontinued lol! You can wear navy in the spring and summer whereas black is too harsh for some colors. And black looks better with black clothing than navy. If you really don't want to keep both then I'd see which one fills a whole in your wardrobe.