I agree with pursekitten that calfskin puzzles are extremely durable bags. I would make your decision based on the color you prefer and the type of leather-smooth versus pebbled. The hardware color doesn’t make much difference on this bag imo. I compared both the tan and the light caramel a couple years ago and preferred the smooth tan color over the pebbled, slightly orangey light caramel color.
A couple years ago I saw the tan puzzle on sale on Ssense.com during blackfriday but it sold out fast. I have bought puzzle bags from Neiman and from Saks during their promotional events and have purchased through rakuten to save an additional 10%. Lately, FP prices have been high for the tan puzzle. It is better to purchase new. The last puzzle I purchased was from bergdorf Goodman. I got 15% off for email sign up and then an additional 10% cash back from rakuten.com. There are ways to save money on these bags. You just have to search a little and sometimes wait a little. Having said that I would pay full price for the puzzle, if I had to, as it is one of my most used bags! It always feels great to get a deal and with the holidays approaching, it’s likely you’ll score a deal. Good luck!
A couple years ago I saw the tan puzzle on sale on Ssense.com during blackfriday but it sold out fast. I have bought puzzle bags from Neiman and from Saks during their promotional events and have purchased through rakuten to save an additional 10%. Lately, FP prices have been high for the tan puzzle. It is better to purchase new. The last puzzle I purchased was from bergdorf Goodman. I got 15% off for email sign up and then an additional 10% cash back from rakuten.com. There are ways to save money on these bags. You just have to search a little and sometimes wait a little. Having said that I would pay full price for the puzzle, if I had to, as it is one of my most used bags! It always feels great to get a deal and with the holidays approaching, it’s likely you’ll score a deal. Good luck!