Hi! Sorry, just now saw this.
I have the Large and it's plenty big. I love huge bags, but I think the XL might be too big? I'm 5'9 and, um meaty, lol.
The Large fits all my daily essentials and there's still some room.
I got mine pre-owned and it looks great, just some minor dings on the corners.
Here's a pic of what I carry daily. Lots of room to spare. I cinch in the sides, cause it looks so cute. You get even more extra space when you don't cinch it in.
View attachment 5957391
And one more, just because.
View attachment 5957392
HTH!