I know, and I simply LOVED your pics! Your pics are one of the reasons that I would choose the lilac as a second CW of this design but I am debating between these two CWs as my first choice because I would never get both since they are so similar
I honestly don’t think you can go wrong with any of the CWs of this design. To me, it’s almost more about the design with this scarf than the CWs, that’s why I think the blanc/gris one works so well too, it’s only an outline but it’s beautiful.
That being said, I know how you feel, went back and forth between pics of CW10 and 14 (the pink one) on my iPad for weeks before finally deciding that 10 would be my top choice. 15 en 16 were options, and 04 too after I saw it IRL, would have been happy with either one of these five. Like you, I only want to buy one CW of a design. (However, if it wasn’t for other scarves I want this season, I would seriously consider getting a second CW.)
With your colouring, I think either one would look great on you! Maybe consider what you already have in your scarf collection? Nothing similar to either one? Or maybe the opposite and one of the CWs resembles a favourite? Which one of the CWs would go with almost anything in your wardrobe? Do you want the scarf to really stand out or blend in? Perhaps you tend to match the colour of a bag, belt or bracelet with a particular colour in a scarf and one of the CWs would be perfect for that? Just some things to maybe take into account. This all under the assumption that you love both CWs equally, if you love one of them just a bit more: ALWAYS go with the one you love the most!!!