I am a mascara addict. Since trying tube mascaras I just can't go back to having to get the black under my eyes off. Right now my faves are:
Trish McEvoy High Volume
Too Faced Lash Injection
Fairy Drops Scandal Queen
I love Benefit's They're Real, but I have a hard time getting the black underneath my eyes off and my lashes tend to fall out more when I'm washing this mascara off. It is my favorite "non-tubing" mascara.