The Best Mascara's I've Ever Used

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

My absolute fave is Diorshow, but not Blackout. I have also started loving Max Factor False Lash Effect (think its called Lash Blast in the USA?) and Rimmel Glam Eyes too - I like it thick and gloopy!!
 
I typically use department store brands (Bare Minerals is my fav) but I thought I'd try a drug store brand - Lash Stiletto. I love it! It's perfect. Nice and black with a great brush for absolutely no clumping.
 
Can anyone recommend a good mascara that won't clump? I have never wore mascara before, yes this is true...because I find it too troublesome but I want to try it out. I have a tendency to chicken out and bought Maybelline Great lash but it sits untouched in my cosmetic bag until it is time to throw it out.
 
I absolutely love Maybelline The Collsal Volum’ Express in Glam Black.

I have long lashes but need volume - this one doesn't clump and really boosts up the body.
 
Hi ladies! Mascara is what started my obsession with makeup so I thought I'd share my absolute faves with you in hopes that you would do the same. These are in no particular order:smile1:

Diorshow Extase

Lancome Definicils Pro

BeneFit They're Real

Maybelline The Colossal Volum' Express

Lancome Hypnose

These have always been my go-to's for huge, black, long lashes. Please share your faves.
 
For whatever reason I can never bring myself to buy high end mascara. It is the one cosmetic that I stick with drugstore brands. I use 3 mascaras currently:

Lash Discovery by Maybelline for my lower lashes.
L'Oreal Voluminous as a base coat on my top lashes
Maybelline The Falsies Volume at the last layer on my top.

Does anyone else use more than one mascara every day?
 
Clinique Lash Power Long-Wearing

I've tried DiorShow and a couple Lancome and I still had problems with flaking. This Clinique mascara is the only one that goes all day without smudging or flaking for me. It washes off with warm water but it doesn't come off in cool water. So if it rains, it still stays put.
 
I once thought DiorShow was the only mascara I was going to use for the rest of my life. BUT Armani's Eyes To Kill completely changed that. I mean, WOW. I have never had such beautiful lashes. Long, black, no clumps but lots of volume.
I recommend it to everyone :p
 
DiorShow Unlimited
YSL Faux Cils #8 Sublime Grey (#9 Noir Radical runs like mad on me; #1 burns my eyes on occasion.)
Revlon GrowLuscious & GrowLuscious Plumping, Blackest Black
Prestige My Biggest Lashes, Very Black
Maybelline Full 'n' Soft, Very Black
Clinique Naturally Glossy, Jet Black
Fusion Beauty LashFusionXL

Must also give shout-outs to Sephora's Lash Perfecting Primer. I never got the chance to try the original Shiseido formula (only the reformulated version; along with Cargo's I think & Hard Candy's 1000 Lashes fiberized one) but I'm in love.
 
Oh there is way too many to name! I'm such a mascara snob, because I'm always on the hunt for the perfect one, but I'll just name some of my faves (not in any order):
YSL Effet Faux Cils
Armani Eyes to Kill
Lancome Doll Lashes
Chantecaille Faux Cils
L'Oreal Voluminous Carbon Black -this one is my all time favorite!;)
L'Oreal Double Extend Lash Boosting
Maybelline The Falsies
Covergirl LashBlast (blue&orange)
Covergirl Lash Perfection
 
Top