The Best Mascara's I've Ever Used

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

I got a free sample of Sephora's Lash plumping new mascara and I gotta say I'm LOVING it so far!! I have to put a layer of waterproof under it so my lashes stay curly but it thickens them up so very nice!

I got the sample too and it's pretty good too!! I find it doesn't give me as much length so I just wear another mascara over it (only 2-3 strokes to give a little length). It stays put all day and doesn't smudge or run...I slept with it on with no problems. Awesome :tup:
 
after trying many mascaras I have to say that I love Chanel inimitable

BUT whenever I wear a mascara I always prefer to use 2 types of mascara at once.......my favorite mascara to wear with Chanel is either Maybelline turbo boost or Lancome.........I always feel really polished after using Chanel as my second coat........I LOVE it!!!
 
Kiss Me "Tube your Lashes"... Eyelash extensions in a tube! I LOVE this mascara. I used Bad Gal Lash before it, and if you like bad gal..you will adore this!
just bought KISS ME mascara in black havent tried it yet and also bought smash box bionic mascara i'll try them in the next 2 days! im excited I love when I get new stuff to experiment with!:tup:
 
i have been reading through this thread and noticed that alot of people recommended Chanel Inimitable got alot of good reviews and I tried it for myself and I am in love with it after the first use!
 
I flirt around with different mascaras- right now I'm trying this loreal kind that I got on sale. Not sure what it's called- it's in a completely silver tube.

BUT. I always seem to fall back on Max Factor 2000 calorie. I love it. Always holds up for at least 14 hours or so. CVS stopped stocking it, and the lady there said that Maybelline bought out the brand, but WalMart seems to have plenty of it... as I bought the last four tubes they had on display in a panic... and now they have another six out on the shelves. :)
 
Something that doesn't lump and clump, like Clinique. Something that doesn't flake like Lancome's Hypnose. I want something that looks like I have fake lashes on, I need something that really adds volume and thickens, the whole nine yards.

My eyes are pretty dark (this is me in my avi) and I need something in a really deep black...

Which do you think are the best mascaras out there? And which are overhyped?
 
Well... I'm sure a lot of people will recommend DiorShow, because it gives that dramatic fake lash look. But at least on me, it clumps, flakes and irritates my eyes like crazy. I still wear it once in awhile, but every time I'm like "Ugh, why did I wear this? :s"

I recommend Bourjois Volume Glamour in Ultra Black. I think it would suit your needs and it's not terribly expensive. I also really like Revlon Fabulash in Blackest Black. It's better than many of the pricey brands I've tried.
 
You know, I've tried the DiorShow too, because of all the hype it gets, and I don't care for it either!

My favorite mascaras are:

Loreal Voluminous - This is just one of the absolute best all around mascaras.

Lancome - L'Extreme - This will definitely give you that false eyelash look. My only beef with it is that once it dries, you cannot really put another layer on because it gets really really stiff.

And always use a primer - Estee Lauder and Lancome both have good ones. Revlon does too, but it comes with a mascara attached, which I'm not so crazy about.

ETA: Also, I prefer waterproof mascaras to regular, because they don't budge!!!
 
Top