TGG, this is precisely the dilemma. I would want to mix this with my other pieces which are mostly yg. The only pg I have is the holiday pendants. Attached, I have a photo that I have saved from an auction site- not sure if it is even authentic or not but it is the closest thing I can find. The photo shows the gray MOP set in yg. I did not feel comfortable asking to take a pic of the bracelet when I was there (believe me I was thinking about it!) as it was not my SO and I didn't feel right doing it. I would have liked to have a comparison photo. In short, both are great. I think it comes down to deciding on individual skin tone. It is a brutal choice for sure! I'm still on the fence as I think pg is a great compliment to gray but yg would mix better I think especially if mixed with 10 motif VA yg. View attachment 3885568
This is exactly my situation!!
I only have the gray mop/pg pendant and perlee hoops in pg. The rest of my collection is either set in yg or pave.
I think PG will be more subtle but YG will pop more. You both have to know what you want from the necklace - PG and grey MOP sounds special [emoji7]