TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others
I would get them in vintage (if I consider what I like most) but I think there is more chance that VCA will release it in VA so paying premium for SO might be less advantageous compared to other two
Hi! I agree with @nightbefore to get Vintage size. Then you can match it with the pendant or 20 motif and it won't be too much. The Magic earring is pretty, but there is a risk it might look like two big fat giant bright blue four leaf lucky charm clover on each side of your face, and you may not wear it often. Maybe try on Magic Malachite earrings as it will give a similar look except green. It's going to either be love at first sight, or hmm... might be a big too much color against my face (you'll know immediately is my guess). Blue Agate and Malachite in a Magic earring is not as neutral on the face as MOP or oynx. I think a Magic MOP is beautiful if you want a Magic earring.
), but you may want to first check with your SA to see if a Blue Agate earring is even an option.Also, I recall the reason why Blue Agate is not offered in earrings is due to the stone transparency, and if they made earrings, you could see through the post which VCA felt was not aesthetically pleasing. I may have dreaming this up (I do dream a lot about VCA and make up pieces
By the way, did you ask for YG or WG? I asked for WG set back around April 24, and they said no to BA in WG.
Hi! I agree with @nightbefore to get Vintage size. Then you can match it with the pendant or 20 motif and it won't be too much. The Magic earring is pretty, but there is a risk it might look like two big fat giant bright blue four leaf lucky charm clover on each side of your face, and you may not wear it often. Maybe try on Magic Malachite earrings as it will give a similar look except green. It's going to either be love at first sight, or hmm... might be a big too much color against my face (you'll know immediately is my guess). Blue Agate and Malachite in a Magic earring is not as neutral on the face as MOP or oynx. I think a Magic MOP is beautiful if you want a Magic earring.
Also, I recall the reason why Blue Agate is not offered in earrings is due to the stone transparency, and if they made earrings, you could see through the post which VCA felt was not aesthetically pleasing. I may be dreaming this up (I do dream a lot about VCA and make up pieces
So exciting! I love Blue Agate, and I hope one day, they will offer it in WG.
Hi there! I'm also interested in doing a SO for the gray MOP/WG Magic earrings. Would it be possible to see any pics? Txs!
I think you should get the Blue Agate in Vintage size. Then, you can get the matching 20 motif in the future.
I know they do wg with Blue Agate in the five motif bracelet because someone I know got it and its beautiful! I don't know why they wouldn't do it in earring style....
Yea the shades vary so much with BA! I wish it wasn’t an SO so I could pick the shade. But I think I will be happy with any of the shades I’ve seen so far.
I asked to SO a set (VA earrings, 20 motif, and 5 motif bracelet). Hmmmm.... Maybe the 20 motif is throwing them off. I’ll wait to hear if others can get WG and BA and then ask again! I haven’t seen the earrings yet.
