I vote for whichever one is easier to read--I know I am old but I've had watches that are nice looking but were so hard to see what the heck time it was due the markers and face being nearly the same. And I also vote for no sticks (I love my roman numerals). And I would have gotten diamond markers except it would have made my watch too pricey and blingy, hence the romans.
Enjoy whatever you choose--you will love your watch!