Side by side comparison pics-

[pixiejenna]

Comparing the large black keep all and the small kelly green keep all.

Jackieusc I have a random question. What is the drop length of the straps on the small keep all versus the large keep all? Its hard to tell, they look like they are the same length on both sizes but maybe my eyes are deceiving me lol. I tried a keep all on once in barneys but I have no idea if it was the large or small size. I really would like the small size over the large because I dont' carry a lot but I like to have a roomy shoulder strap. I hate what I call "pit purses" when the shoulder straps are so short the purse is wedged up in your armpit. TIA!

 

[batgirl416]

Jackieusc I have a random question. What is the drop length of the straps on the small keep all versus the large keep all? Its hard to tell, they look like they are the same length on both sizes but maybe my eyes are deceiving me lol. I tried a keep all on once in barneys but I have no idea if it was the large or small size. I really would like the small size over the large because I dont' carry a lot but I like to have a roomy shoulder strap. I hate what I call "pit purses" when the shoulder straps are so short the purse is wedged up in your armpit. TIA!

@ pixiejenna: From the website, handle drop are as follows:
Large Keepall = 8"
Small Keepall = 5"

 

[pixiejenna]

@ pixiejenna: From the website, handle drop are as follows:
Large Keepall = 8"
Small Keepall = 5"

Thanks Batgirl! I'm half thinking it was a large I tried on, maybe I need to go back and try it on again .

 

[batgirl416]

Thanks Batgirl! I'm half thinking it was a large I tried on, maybe I need to go back and try it on again .

@ pixiejenna: You're welcome. I have been considering a Large Keepall as well. Lucky you to have a PS nearby. If I did have a store nearby, I would hang and stalk it until I can finally decide which colour of large KAll to get. Right now, I'm still as confused as ever: Midnight (1st choice), Saddle and Black (tied for 2nd choice). If only Midnight were in stock, then it will be so much easier.

What colour were you thinking of getting?

 

[Micole]

Jackieusc I have a random question. What is the drop length of the straps on the small keep all versus the large keep all? Its hard to tell, they look like they are the same length on both sizes but maybe my eyes are deceiving me lol. I tried a keep all on once in barneys but I have no idea if it was the large or small size. I really would like the small size over the large because I dont' carry a lot but I like to have a roomy shoulder strap. I hate what I call "pit purses" when the shoulder straps are so short the purse is wedged up in your armpit. TIA!

Too funny! I hate that too. Whenever I see someone sporting their bag in that way I have to fight the urge to say: "Clearly, that is NOT a shoulder bag!" That's part of the brilliance of the Keep All. It really is designed for all options..

 

[pixiejenna]

@ pixiejenna: You're welcome. I have been considering a Large Keepall as well. Lucky you to have a PS nearby. If I did have a store nearby, I would hang and stalk it until I can finally decide which colour of large KAll to get. Right now, I'm still as confused as ever: Midnight (1st choice), Saddle and Black (tied for 2nd choice). If only Midnight were in stock, then it will be so much easier.

What colour were you thinking of getting?

I have a barneys nearish(in the city I'm in the burbs). But they have a limited stock so i havent seen all the colors yet. But every time I go to the city I do stalk them lol. I'm thinking I might want military or saddle two colors I haven't seen yet lol.

 

[pixiejenna]

Too funny! I hate that too. Whenever I see someone sporting their bag in that way I have to fight the urge to say: "Clearly, that is NOT a shoulder bag!" That's part of the brilliance of the Keep All. It really is designed for all options..

I don't get how people can wear them that way?! I think it's uncomfortable having something wedged in your armpit or even close to it.

 

[jackieusc]

Pixiejenna- Just looked at this today! Sorry for the late reply!
My small green handles fit over my big arms EASY! So the large black will either be the same or longer! Love this bag!

Jackieusc I have a random question. What is the drop length of the straps on the small keep all versus the large keep all? Its hard to tell, they look like they are the same length on both sizes but maybe my eyes are deceiving me lol. I tried a keep all on once in barneys but I have no idea if it was the large or small size. I really would like the small size over the large because I dont' carry a lot but I like to have a roomy shoulder strap. I hate what I call "pit purses" when the shoulder straps are so short the purse is wedged up in your armpit. TIA!

 

[pixiejenna]

Pixiejenna- Just looked at this today! Sorry for the late reply!
My small green handles fit over my big arms EASY! So the large black will either be the same or longer! Love this bag!

NP I'm still going to have to think about it lol. If it's a true 5 in drop on the small that will be too uncomfortable for me to wear on my shoulder. I'm really thinking I tried on a large at barneys. If the weather wasn't so stormy I'd head out there today to look.

 

[HandbagAngel]

I have always wanted to post the comparison photos between PS1 Large and Keep All Small. Finally got a chance to take them. Please excuse me the poor lighting since it is night here.


They are about the same height:

Keep All Small is wider than PS1 Large, the bottom is also deeper

 

[lovemyangels]

Very helpful comparison photos! I think Keep All Small is exactly what I need.

 

[Micole]

I have always wanted to post the comparison photos between PS1 Large and Keep All Small. Finally got a chance to take them. Please excuse me the poor lighting since it is night here.


They are about the same height:

Keep All Small is wider than PS1 Large, the bottom is also deeper

Amazing!! What's the difference in weight?

 

[HandbagAngel]

Amazing!! What's the difference in weight?

I used a stupid way - carried them seperately with me and weighted myself on the scale twice. They turned out the same. But I held them on my hands and felt PS1 Larger is slightly heavier than KA Small.

 

[riry]

I used a stupid way - carried them seperately with me and weighted myself on the scale twice. They turned out the same. But I held them on my hands and felt PS1 Larger is slightly heavier than KA Small.

You're so cute, HandbagAngel! I can just picture you carrying each bag and stepping on/off/on/off the scale.

Thanks for this helpful comparison shot.

 

[ehemelay]

Photos of Medium PS1 vs. Large PS1:

PS tag on 2011 PS1 (attached to the ring) vs. 2010 PS1 (attached to the strap):